His boat wait
by Rino63

Comment:
Nice Photo, prehaps a little too closely cropped. Some extra space to the left, and some extra sky may have made this even better.
However, its a stretch to consider this as meeting the topic.

He's been on tour rockin' out with his band- The Village (Burnin') People!!!
by taterbug

Comment:
Great idea for the topic. The direct lighting from the side has cast some shadows that maybe are a little harsh. It gives the photo a very Black look. A slightly different angle, or a little bit of light from a different direction to get some extra light on the guitar head may have helped??????

Art is: Riding The Rails
by fldave

Comment:
The overall grey look does not work for me. There is noise from the post processing obvious which detracts from the photo. The crop I think is too close on the left, more room was needed. There also doesn't appear to be any true white or black. Adjusting the levels such that both black and white were int he photo may have improved the look of this photo.
Also, even with the title, its a stretch on the topic for this shot.

The United States of...?
by bigj

Comment:
I wonder what type of President Art would make, not to get into a political debate here (seeing I'm an aussie)
Something different, well thought out and well executed. I like the composition of the shot, and the way it ties in with the challenge. Not sure the white border adds to your photo though.

Next time you should spend longer than 11 days in Australia......

Frozen solid ???
by anferh

Comment:
Interesting photo. Nice effect you have acheived here. However the black and white gives a very bleak look, and makes it somehow less interesting.....

Also, even with the Title, not really fitting in with the Challenge for me

Alone With His Thoughts
by alanfreed

Comment:
A very interesting picture of Yellow Seats. What should have been a boring shot has turned out well due to the patterns thaat appear in the seats. A great angle on the photo. Exposure is good, and the person in the photo is able to be tied to the topic well.

Art is in a world of color and beauty
by cogerox

Comment:
A good landscape photo, really like the colours theough the sky and the reflections which you have through the still water. The flatness of the land though means it is less appealing than it could have been, as there is little subject other than the sky in this photo.

Also, the lack of anything really tied to the topic affects the score.

I heard he had been hanging out with the Indian Goddess Durga.
by aKiwi

Comment:
Interesting photo you have here Even with the title, for me it struggles to meet the challenge, but ignoring that....
The overexposed areas of skin on the first person are distracting. The light needed to be less intense from the front, or, as this was Advaned Editing rules, this could have been selectively fixed during PP. The lack of expression also does not appeal.

He might be in there somewhere
by Pico

Comment:
I am not a fan of the post processing you have used for this. For me, it totally detracts from the photo. The topic says it all, he could be in there, but due to the PP, I wouldn't be able to tell.
It appears the original may have been very busy, and hence maybe why you chose this way of doing things.

red bottle
by soeren

Comment:
Noise is a problem here that detracts from the image. Also, some fill light to light the rest of the bottle would have helped