Open and Pour (frosted glass optional)
by nycpawnpusher

Comment:
I cant believe, you didn't get a ribbon out of this one. I agree with magenmarie, this shot deserves better. :-)

Open and Pour (frosted glass optional)
by nycpawnpusher

Comment:
The entrant has successfully utilized noise to its advantage, adding to the overall softness which works well with this photo. Nicely Done!

Margarita Noir
by AP

Comment:
The effective use of selective desaturation leads the viewers to focus on the main subject of this image. The directional lighting employed created a sparkle on the face further emphasizing the cocktail.

As to editing, considering the limitations imposed on the entrants, this went quite well. 7/10

Pesto
by Iraklis

Comment:
Off Topic

Sprite
by leematthews

Comment:
Although the challenge is based on basic editing, the entry should have been given much thought and preparation. It would be very unfair if i judged this based solely on editing and not give points for other criteria such as concept, lighting, composition and the overall look to which the other entries excel.

In spite of the limitations on the amount of editing work which could be performed on this photograph, much could have been done to improve this image through cropping, tone/color adjustments and the likes. Nevertheless a point for being on topic :-)

Expolding Shot
by Tirasco

Comment:
The overall concept of this photo does not coincide with the subject matter which is Recipe(Beverage). Although the shot of a wine glass or bottle gives a hint, the blue flame and the broken glass suggests this as more of a scientific experiment than a drink. Although i give credit to the preparation and execution of this shot as clearly much time and effort was devoted in creating it.

As to editing, considering the limitations imposed on the entrants, i say its good. Overall I give the photo a 6/10.

101 ways to make coffee
by tjmueller

Comment:
Simple. But vividly sharp & clear :-)

T E A
by bnilesh

Comment:
I like the way you used coffee or coffee like material as your background and give good contrast to the image. Initially gave a 7. But I changed my mind. + 1
8/10

Dry
by rinac

Comment:
Perfect! :-)

Tea's Up!
by Pug-H

Comment:
The shot could have worked if on the normal orientation, which exudes that refreshingly warm feeling especially on cold days where a hot cup of tee would be nice.

Aside from the neck straining angle, over all concept and composition is OK, editing is good although the highlights could have been tweaked a little on the low side (its just me. I score this 6/10. Could have garnered an 7 or 8 if upside down :-)