Celestial Clock
by ososnilknarf

Comment:
Nice. That smudge to the right, something that happened in PP? I assume it is the noice reduction, that screwed up the star trails further from the north star? Perhaps you could have darkened it all, to bring out the stars better, and tone down the ground. Lifting the angle to clear the trees would have been beneficial and given you more stars (but you probably didn't even see them in the dark).

Nothing.
by Tom

Comment:
You did the best out of it, though. I like it!

Here Comes The Night
by Kwilson10

Comment:
Brave. I find this somewhat lacking in the technical and artistic departments. Almost a full set of grays, though;)

Artificial Illumination
by emu2008

Comment:
Add a "Line" to the challenge title, and you are in the box. But what's in a word, right?

Twinkle Twinkle
by raish

Comment:
Well, you got a good laugh from me! Good thing I wasn't eating. Pure genius. Focus, composition, colours - spot on;) You just have to hope that people don't have dirty screens (mine is a borderline case). A 10 for creativity (and to balance the poor sods who don't get it...).

Under the rainbow
by nickstyle

Comment:
Night sky with a double rainbow might be stretching the task just a bit too far. I can see why you wanted to share it anyway, though. A fantastic moment, no doubt. PP is a matter of taste, of course. For me, something else might have been tastier.

What my night sky looked like, they were beaming our people up...
by picturesbykim

Comment:
Nice one! The trees could be a bit sharper, and I find your frame unduly heavy. Some cropping from the right, perhaps? And how about placing that flash just a bit further to the right...;)

The Open Sky
by gaurav

Comment:
Nice little cloud there, and the gradient has potential. I'm not too thrilled by the vignetting, the noice and the lens dust smudge (?), though.

Eagle Nebula, M16
by CyMaN

Comment:
I take it, that this is not the kit 18-200 lens, even with a 1,6 teleconverter, right? Amazing what you can find up there, given a good telescope and knowing where to look. Great shot!

Salar de Uyuni Sunrise
by beamsclan

Comment:
Surreal. The lower third is stunning, the rest I'm not so sure about. The stars look an awful lot like hot pixels to me.