Less Filling
by rickhd13

Comment:
Interesting aspect ratio, kind of door-postery. The half-glass shot doesn't thrill me although at least it's different. Nice foamy beer, and I like the choice of background.

Iced Thai 'Impresso'
by Havok

Comment:
Mmm. Chai.

Darn it! Starbucks is CLOSED this time of night! I hate you! I hate you and everyone who looks like you!

*ahem* Right. Comments on the PICTURE, right. Um. My only real complaint is the very bright background and the way the logo almost fades into it. I like the focus on the condensation, and the close-up shot.

Liquid Electricity
by Fiver

Comment:
Erm. Is this a non-water thing? Looks vaguely bubbly, so probably. Interesting concept but it doesn't do much for me, and that strange fuschia highlight sort of ruins the blue-toned look.

My Goodness My Guinness
by Alecia

Comment:
Nice shadow. Looks like your Guiness glass has actual guiness in it too from the tone and the foam, though that's harder to tell in B&W since you can't see the chewy brown colour. I like the tilt. Top right there's some light reflection that's a little distracting, and not sure what that background is but I think a more solid colour would have suited slightly better.

Oil Giant
by renzo

Comment:
Wellllll... it looks sort of like a planet photo, though it's not quite perfectly round enough for it -- I'm not really sure what it is, and so I can't tell how liquidy it really is.

aahhh
by ellamay

Comment:
I anticipate a lot of people-drinking photos. It's on-topic. The shot is good, interesting play of shades of grey, good lighting and sharp focus.

ambeer
by pupparazzo

Comment:
Okay, if I drank beer, which I don't, I would think of this as a very enticing commercial shot, so nice job. A bit too much bright blur on the label and that funky flame-like artifact at the top is, well, funky, but the way the light hits the glass is great.

Through the bottle ...
by ursula

Comment:
It's a neat idea, but the way the letters get blurred is not visually pleasing.

Martini Anyone?
by URBANREMIXdotCOM

Comment:
I really dislike the red tone. The blur is unfortunate -- would have worked with a martini shaker but not this way IMO. And the lighting is way too bright on the glass by comparison to the rest.

SNOT!
by smellyfish1002

Comment:
Okay, EWW.

But, er, I suppose strictly speaking it meets the challenge. And it's a nice close-up shot aside from the ugh factor...