Logitech Abstract
by JPR

Comment:
I neither care for nor understand the point of the big white border line to the left. It's just distracting to me.

In terms of lighting I like this. Otherwise, well, it's the bottom of a mouse, and it doesn't terribly interest me, though it meets the topic fine.

Milk... It Does A Body...
by tolyanchik

Comment:
Skim milk. Ick.

Considering how much of the required elements of your photo (milk, milk carton) are white, I think I would have chosen a different, even if not terribly darker, coloured stuffed animal. Also the lighting in this seems rather bright but it may be an artifact of teh chosen colours.

I like the basic idea, and the framing is not bad though maybe shifting the center just a bit downwards so the glass isn't almost sitting on the edge would have been nicer... some of that's a reaction to the homogenous colour scheme, though.

Snow melt rushing to Coors for conversion to BEER!
by jimsapp

Comment:
The actual visible liquid in this is water. Water was off-topic. A beer factory is not liquid, even if it produces it. The bright red border is very distracting. The photo is fine in terms of focus but as it's of a muddy river and a factory it doesn't do much for me attractiveness.

#244: Surf N' Blue
by carolee

Comment:
Good use of gold at the bottom for contrast. Top contrast is not as vivid but the tight focus helps with that. Topic is fine. Maybe a bit too clean and neat.

Is It In You?
by greenem2

Comment:
This will make a lot more sense to people who have seen the ads. Luckily for you, I have.

It's an interesting idea, but to mimic the ads you would have needed somewhat different lighting. Having the colour-on-B&W helps with the impression but it's too bright to meet my expectations.

Hmm. Now that I think about it, maybe you'll be better off with the people who do NOT know the ad campaign....

Sealing Liquid
by snowleopard10101

Comment:
I think I like the basic idea, but this ends up very cluttered and noisy on a colour level. More even rows of bottles, maybe set off slightly each row, might have helped. Alternating colours might have helped; right now they're kind of grouped. Fewer bottles would have been the other choice.

...They Will Come
by mindyparker

Comment:
If you drip it... ?

Well, it looks too viscous to be water, that's good. I'm guessing honey or sap or something in that range. The focal blur at the foreground is very distracting, takes the eyes away from the focal point; raising the angle just slightly might have helped with that. Good close-up shot.

Perfume
by Bukios

Comment:
On the plus side, I've yet to see anyone else use perfume this round. Good going!

On the minus, I don't care for the background this is set against at all. It's very distracting, and doesn't really do much to set off the bottle.

Oil & Alcohol
by jodiecoston

Comment:
I do like the pattern of bubbles. The blurred background being so much brighter is very distracting -- I think it would have been better with more light on the foreground.

Golden Tears
by tommy_t

Comment:
I have no clue what your liquid is other than it's obviously highly reflective. I kind of like the fact the face is visible, it gives it a bit more interest. I think just having those drops would have actually been a better shot, as the ones without an obvious reflection don't add as much to the shot for me.