My entertainment center
by camelotnorth

Comment:
An interesting the shot, but the posterising (or similar) filter completely detracts for me. 4

Loud
by pitsaman

Comment:
Stunning picture, but not low-key. 6

Plastic Surgery
by DrJOnes

Comment:
Wow, what a figure! Emma Peel in bondage...(!)
I feel that you missed the opportunity to explore the moodiness and darkness that a low-key image could have produced, IMO there are too many highlights, and not enough exploration of the darker tones. The glares don't work for me here. Other than that, very arresting photo! 8

Tread Darkly
by moodville

Comment:
Great subject for challenge. Shame about the graininess, too many highlights on the boot for my taste. Otherwise, effective mood. 8

Back In Black
by sher

Comment:
Haha, this is how I kept seeing those words... I think you may even have an SG there (albeit a copy)!
Great concept, nice mood, good textures. Like the sharpness of the 'Marshall' logo. Graininess of guitar works well. Like the cropping, and angle of guitar.
My favourite pic this challenge, you met the challenge well. 9

Wildfowl Carving Magazine
by camelotnorth

Comment:
Mediocre lighting, don't like the shadow. Not very saturated. Don't like the cropping, would like to see more of the left hand side of the photo. I don't think the table was a good choice of base... the wood grain doesn't do anything to help your main subject. However, there's a certain character to this I like. 6

The Gardener
by Jonatan

Comment:
Aw, that's much better than any picture of a dandelion I've ever taken! Nice contrast between the white and the green background. Nice dof. Not sure i'd see it on the front of any magazine about gardening though. 7

PC World
by Sappy

Comment:
What on earth is that thing? Intesting use of light, a bit of glare in places though. Composition a bit cluttered for my taste. 7

Practical Photography
by dasser

Comment:
Brilliant, great textures and composition. Good concept. Really nice skin tones. Only thing that spoils it are the eyes... the reflection of the wood in her left eye cuts across her pupil, lessening the impact of the photo. 9

Outdoor Photographer
by progersct

Comment:
Wonderful photo... love the female silhouette. Her hair works especially well. Not sure about the placement of the sun just off-centre here. Dead-on centre or to one side would have worked better for me. The ducks are a little distracting as well. Love the foreground leaves. 9