Mosaic Mirror
by Heavy

Comment:
The mirror itself is interesting, however, the reflections inside the small mirrors are not. I think it would look better if the subject was in focus and of some interest.

Subtle Reflections
by ws6_ta

Comment:
A bit too centered and looks slightly overprocessed. I would leave some negative space on the right side of the frame and maybe a bit more at the top.

mirror image
by claudia26

Comment:
Not the most imaginative or creative photo in the challenge. However, you captured very nice tonal balance of the skin with only one bright spot on the shoulder. Details of the hair are sharp and clear.

Last Dance, First Kiss
by dan_pendleton

Comment:
This would a great DOF shot (sans people) but it's extremely difficult to make out what they are doing since they are so blurry.

What a stud!
by parrothead

Comment:
Very cute photo of a horse admiring himself in the mirror. Nice details and composition. Great job of getting the horse to look right into the camera via the mirror, too.

Autumn
by Jesuispeure

Comment:
Looks like the type of scene you see in commercials of people looking for something in the attic and there always seems to be a mirror up there. Model looks very relaxed and is pondering something. Love the duotone and the textures of the floor and hair seem to complement each other very well. Well composed but the upper left corner of the frame seems a bit overexposed. I looked at this a second time and thought about the upper left corner a lot. It gives a nice balance to the opposite corner of the frame and it seems to work well especially since there's more lighter parts of the frame than darker parts. In my opinion, darker portions would ask for more attention away from the main subject. 9

Mirror Of Nature
by Dufus

Comment:
This my favorite of the challenge. The simplicity of the idea is amazing and works very well. Contrast is a bit blown out in the real sky (not reflected sky) but that makes me want to focus more on the mirror and trace the lines. Not that I like overexposed skies but it's not as distracting here. Plus the frame forces the eye to look there and the color forces the eye even more. A solid 9 but since I love this shot so much, I'll give it a 10.

Refreshing Reflections
by mocabela

Comment:
Great shot! Love the strong contrast of this shot. Those are my favorite type of b/w or duotone shots. Things I feel are missing are perhaps some ice cubes in the drink and a less distracting reflection on the right. The reflections of the glass are very interesting but if you want to maximize focus time on the glass, make the most of it. Give the eyes something to look at. I think you had an overhead light source so even a plain reflection would have worked as well or maybe a dark gray to show the drops on the glass surface. And to be really nitpicky, wax the glass surface so the water beads vs spreading. Otherwise, I really enjoyed this photo. Good job! 7

Windows to the Soul
by Coley

Comment:
Oh man, this one made me laugh out loud! Big bug eyes! Great creativity and use of selective desat. My sole complaint is the model's forehead as it's slightly overexposed. 7

looking at myself
by mizz_kt_bug

Comment:
Interesting composition is flawed by harsh and direct flash lighting. If this is an external flash, try using bounce/fill flash if possible. Or try a softbox. Short of that, try some kleenex in front of the flash to help diffuse and soften the light.