Table Sugar
by Sting11165

Comment:
Was this a Shallow DOF outtake?

Forget the beef, where's the cheese?
by cwalmye

Comment:
Good catch (or nice idea, if its a pet hamster or something). Unfortunately the focus is behind the subject, which leaves the edges unsharp and ruins the silhouette you are going for by softening the edges too much.

The light of Knowledge
by saurongt

Comment:
Great use of the challenge. I really like the angle you used in this shot. Even though you don't see the table, its clearly a table-high angle. Focus is a little soft in the near field (a smaller aperture would help here) and highlights are a bit blown out at the top and far end. Also would have been nice to see a figure in one of the chairs at the end of the aisle, perhaps bent over a book, but still very nice as it is. 8

Tavolina e Umberto Ekos
by gjumi

Comment:
Very nice composition, with a hint of the table at the bottom. Well done

The Baker
by jrjr

Comment:
Great detail and composition, and creative use of the challenge.

minimal possibilities
by h2

Comment:
Great idea, well done

Sinking
by Hipychik

Comment:
I can't find anything to say I don't like about this picture. The lighting is good, the blacks are deep, the focus is sharp, the composition is appropriate ... technically excellent. As a whole, though, the image leaves me underwhelmed. Can't say precisely why that is; maybe its just that images like this have been done many times before. But then again, I could say the same thing about most of the flower shots in this challenge, and they don't hit me the same way. I'm not trying to be overly critical here (I gave you a 7); just sharing my reaction.

New Moon
by Tim

Comment:
Nice sky capture and detail

Lone Lily Bud
by kevip6

Comment:
Very simple, very nice

Spice Haiku
by pepitoid

Comment:
Nicely composed. The berry could have been a bit sharper; sharpness seems to fall off a bit in the bottom third of the image.