El Calafate
by Pano

Comment:
Interesting. I'd be intrigued to know why you didn't shoot the area with more of these things. This is just fine as it stands - a suitably odd subverting of a normally pretty landscape - but it's clear from this image that there were several other options. One stump is interesting - more than one ...

| I |
by PhotoRyno

Comment:
Nice mood, though personally I find it lacking in anything more than just mood - not quite enough to stand out for me these days; there are so many good mood photographs.

Luring
by pinbokeshatta

Comment:
I like. Not wholly sold on the metal tonality, as i think it might have been interesting enough in simple black and white: likewise I wonder if you might not have made more of the shapes and patterns within the water. A fine contemplative study nevertheless.

Christmas Day
by elru21

Comment:
A bit twee for my taste, but excellently done for what it is. The foreground bokeh is nice too - though that's a bugbear for many, as I expect some will have commented.

A Study in Light and Shadow
by tfarrell23

Comment:
My first challenge here was 'The Egg' - some 200 later, I still have the feeling that it makes for a far more difficult subject than most would admit of. Strong sense of texture here, well handled lighting, good composition.

William Turner Goes Modern
by rembo

Comment:
I quite like this - it has a degree of photographic integrity that is missing from many images around here - that is, you've kept it feeling like a photograph rather than an illustration. I'm not totally sold on this composition - perhaps the sun is too far right in frame, perhaps the car doesn't intrude enough to feel like a genuine element ... not sure.

Ruapehu by the Lake
by rayz1

Comment:
Good groove and colours - the foreground seems to have been knocked a bit by (presumably) the increase of contrast elsewhere.

Sitting Pretty
by whiteroom

Comment:
There's an odd sensation of her being slightly disconnected from her environment; like she's floating, almost. I think the location - the shapes given to this image by the stairs and so on, might have been handled slightly better, making them a stronger contributor to the composition rather than simply a background, which is how they seem here.

Jetty on Tuggerah Lake
by Cammac

Comment:
Given the smallness of those birds in frame anyway, I think you'd have been well advised to use the full available size limit - and from a purely graphic design point of view I think the brown outer border is a mistake. It might have had a nice even winter groove to it, but it's hard to get past those elements really. Strong use of leading lines to make the centred composition comfortable though.

Ringling's sunset
by illoosi0n

Comment:
Gosh, looks odd - some kind of over-smoothing thing going on? Funny selections and all that? Don't like that feel much.