She'll Be Grown Before You Know It
by Photologist

Comment:
Vignetting feels a bit forced; strong composition though; won't be surprised if you get some challenge-relevance comments.

vacation
by agenkin

Comment:
Interesting composition - almost a pity about the plane, given the strangeness of a bloke pulling a vacuum cleaner across the tarmac. Nice treatment too, though perhaps in the end the difficulty, composition-wise, of the placement of the plane does for the final effect.

I REALLY need to get that garage finished
by ShutterPug

Comment:
I think your white balance has drifted a touch too far to the blue; more unfortunately for the image is, I think, the composition: too many extraneous elements crowd the upper part of frame, and then the lower part is absolutely simple. You might, for instance, have made the same point with a shot solely of the snow on the vehicle - there must be some interesting forms and lines made by that snow covering, and we'd only need to see the snow on the vehicle to know that the garage wasn't finished, no?

In 2006 I thought about updating my will...
by photom1946

Comment:
I'd say this needs some processing, or simply some moment of light that is more interesting than this very flat moment: there's no shape to those columns, no strong sense of organisation to the bare branches, and the gravestones are almost completely lost.

To Dream A Little More
by Judi

Comment:
I/R? The most interesting I/R image I've seen, if it is. I dislike the twee-ness of it, the sentimentality, but i do like the shapes and details of the ferns and leaves.

Back to College (When I Quit Procrastinating)
by SandyP

Comment:
Nice simple image, thought-out composition, effective light. Can you tell it doesn't excite me much? After the raft of truly dreadful stuff in this challenge though, it's great to see just a well crafted image.

Going to Church
by StuckOnTheFarm

Comment:
Good postcard image; I wonder if some will consider this shoe-horned in to the challenge, but I think it's well enough done to prevent that happening. i'm no huge fan of this really, but after some truly awful photographs, it's interesting to see something simply well photographed.

My Garage - My Nemesis
by timfythetoo

Comment:
Amidst that chaos, I think we need to have some formal movement to draw the eye through this image: some repetition, some specific colours, some leading lines, some distribution through the frame.

Got the truck runnin' yet?
by NikonJeb

Comment:
Very straightforward image - the obvious standing-up point of view, framing simply to include the edges of the truck, colour just accurate. This then, depends for its impact only on the subject, rather than the photographers relation to it, and that won't be enough to engage people's attention.

Mending the Barn
by skewsme

Comment:
Almost posterized feeling colours, most un-photographic seeming to me.