Galleria
by Clou9

Comment:
Composition: Good
Technical: The focus seems good, but this pic is very dark for me. I can't tell what the subject is bottom-right, which I assume I should be able to.
Meets challenge: Push it a little..
Overall impression: With more contrast could have been much better. 4

Dare to Be Square
by karmat

Comment:
Composition: Good. Really like the background and table surface
Technical: Fantastic focus, good use of colour, nice border. Looks like you've sharpened after you added the border not before (white line between pic and border). Best to do it before added the border.
Meets challenge: Yes
Overall impression: Technically great and aesthetic too! 8

Clark Park
by JPR

Comment:
Composition: Excellent
Technical: Great focus. Maybe slightly dark, but I don't think it's detrimental to the pic.
Meets challenge: Yes
Overall impression: Nice idea and shot, good tech. 8

Krab
by magnetic9999

Comment:
Composition: Great
Technical: Excellent focus and lighting/shadow. Pic seems slightly dark? Good choice of border.
Meets challenge: Yes
Overall impression: Really good, but would have preferred it slightly lighter personally. 7

Hip To Be Square
by Slimharpo

Comment:
Composition: Good
Technical: Slightly noisy. Right-hand pieces seem a little dark? Would possibly have chosen a slightly less vibrant coloured piece to fit in with the pic.
Meets challenge: This looks like it has been edited with a brush/etc, which is a BIG no no.
Overall impression: Could have been really nice, but lacking on the above points. Without spot editing: 5, With: 0.

Fifteen?
by steinarknutsen

Comment:
Composition: Good. Would have been tempted to centralise the letters horz (less space near E).
Technical: Good colour and lighting. Focus seems slightly off around R and E? Seems slightly noisy?
Meets challenge: Yes
Overall impression: Focus lets it down slightly, but otherwise, great pic. 7

MULT COLOR
by kevinswope

Comment:
Composition: Excellent. As soon as I saw this pic I turned my head 45 degrees to try and work out what they are.
Technical: Excellent. Not completely sure about the orange background. Maybe a darker colour?
Meets challenge: Yes
Overall impression: I love interesting photos, and you've got this one pretty spot on. 9

basketballs
by Wheeler1992

Comment:
Composition: Good
Technical: I think lack of light could have let this down, but you pulled it off nicely. Focus seems slightly off apart from the bottom-right ball.
Meets challenge: Pushing it a bit.
Overall impression: Nice shot, good tech, but challenge criteria lets it down. 6

Gvmt Building - Bunch of squares...
by kosmikkreeper

Comment:
Composition: Good, although the dark reflect on the left seems to throw the pic out of balance a little
Technical: Good focus and colour. Good size. May have chosen a thin border, but maybe that looked bad with the window frames..
Meets challenge: Yes
Overall impression: Good choice of shot, but would have preferred a different angle I think. 6

Church Door
by goodtempo

Comment:
Composition: Maybe would have zoomed in on the square part more.
Technical: Nice focus, colour and contrast. Texture of the wood looks great.
Meets challenge: Yes
Overall impression: Really nice and hard to fault. 7