Eddiditfirst
by p2jvr

Comment:
This is a really great shot, and one of the few pictures of "a simple tree out in nature" that I do enjoy. Of course, this challenge is flooded with them, so that makes it all the more difficult for photos like this to stand out. That being said, your composition, awareness of color, and only very subtle apparent post modification help it to remain loking pure and striking. The sky is great as well - you definitely picked the right time to snap the shutter. My only real critique would be to try to up the creativity level for next time - it's obvious you have an eye for a shot, so stretch yourself a little for future challenges. I do think there's a fine line between setting up a photo that spells out the challenge theme creatively and just being downright goofy, but as long as you approach it with care you'll be fine. This is one of my favorites in the competition.

First Sprinkle
by SherwinJames

Comment:
Really nice shot - the composition, color, and sharpness are all spot on, and I like the simplicity of the subject. I see too many photographs try to cram too much into the frame, and although this is clearly shot in a controlled environment, the elements used are completely appropriate. The mist adds a great layer to the picture that really makes it so powerful - without it, it would just be a picture of a well lit tree (and there certainly are plenty of those). There is something about studio shots (call them contrived, perhaps) that makes me feel a little bit removed from the subject - there's just something about a candid, natural photo that lends itself to greatness - but I have no doubts you will do spectacularly in this competition. All of the pieces are in the right place, and I really can't find much to criticize.

Intruder
by e301

Comment:
Phenomenal. Love the color, the depth, the texture. My only wish was that it was night outside - I think that would've added a little more to the fantasy element of this photograph and also helped to secure the viewer's focus completely on the tree. I don't like seeing some of the distracting elements outside of the window. That being said, good use of dodging and burning - that definitely seems to be the style of choice these days (though I like it). As it stands, this is my favorite entry in the competition.

Bent But Not Broken
by jrjr

Comment:
I really love the colors in this one, but it looks a little too post-processed. The dodging is very noticable on the tree - especially near the tip where it actually starts to bleed into the clouds! Just remember, everything in moderation (the fade control is your friend!). Otherwise, the composition and tone is really nice. Great eye for the shot.