The Difference One Day Makes
by rebs138

Comment:
The alinement of the bird and the egg really makes this image. You might want to consider a square crop that includes just the in focus portion of the nest. The out of focus portion and the greenery are non-benefical negative space imho. 8

Milk For Me!
by bnilesh

Comment:
The focus on the eyes is tack sharp like it is supposed to be. The lighting is a bit harsh and the background has several distractions.

Another Parking Lot Coming Soon!
by haircut

Comment:
This image conveys progress very well but the focal point is on the curb instead of the de-construction in the background. If the heavy machinery was in focus, you could crop off the bottom half of this image and have a much stronger entry.

Practice, Practice, Practice
by judojoe

Comment:
The photo says Pose, Pose, Pose not Practice, Practice, Practice, as the subjects are looking directly at the camera. I like the sepia tone and the film grain feel to this image but if the image had a bit of motion blur it would have conveyed practice a bit more strongly.

Centuries Apart
by Firsty

Comment:
The color tone of this image are very interesting and work very nicely imho. The costume looks a bit fake and cropping at the ankles hurts the composition of the photo.

Are We There Yet? (Getting Closer)
by daz311x

Comment:
The technical aspects of this image are well done (exposure, focus, selective desaturation). The image has very little emotional content imho and probably not score very well.

Solitary Stillness
by ShutterPug

Comment:
I have only one comment to make regarding this image, superb photography. I gave this an 8 and I didn't even know it was a UP frog (MTU alumni).

...at the Station
by MikeO

Comment:
The B&W conversion here is exceptional. The lighting on the couple helps to emphasize that they are the main "stationary" subjects of this image. I gave this a 9 because it is superb.

Going nowhere fast
by DJWoodward

Comment:
I rated this image a 9, as I really think you nailed the composition and framing of this image. I even like the brightness of the roof, as it helps show just how exposed to the elements this old truck really is. I agree with glad2badad regarding the contrast and levels. Hope my first challenge entry is as good as this image.

Parked
by bigj

Comment:
I didn't comment on this image during the challenge because I thought it would score much higher and receive a lot of positive feedback. The contrast and lighting in this image is truely wonderful. If you would have moved over just a little bit to eliminate the partial car in the background, I would have given this a 10 instead of a 9. Nice job.