Road to Home
by farmer48

Comment:
In the autumn, it's probably a 9, but in winter a 6. Nice enough but not outstanding.

Singled Out
by pearlseyes

Comment:
The bottom right hand corner is a little distracting. Nice scene but could have been better with more emphasis on the tree and mountains. 5

Madrone
by Blackbox

Comment:
Nice contrast and DOF. 7

"Sentry of Decades"
by Weefan

Comment:
The really interesting tree is lost in the really un-interesting background. Nice lighting and foreground whispy stuff. 6

Starry Night at the Treehouse
by jasonlprice

Comment:
I like the idea, but I think you exposed a little too long. The stars lose interest when they're that "streaky" and the tree house is a little bright. Cool tree though. 5

Reach
by SherwinJames

Comment:
Interesting POV, but not an interesting scene. 5

Sun Kissed Snow
by Hipychik

Comment:
7 - Great capture of the sky's colors and silhouette of the trees, branches. Personal taste brought it down a point because of the sun. Good luck.

Lone Cypress
by arnie700

Comment:
Nice composition. The main thing that detracts is the lighting. Harsh sunlight. 5

undercover
by facesastheycome

Comment:
Nice symmetry of tress. A little later in the day would have given more interesting sky. 5

~a tree~
by oravsky123

Comment:
I especially like the ground and background meadow. the tree works well presnented as dark as you have done. I know all horizons aren't straight, but the leading lines of the foreground hill and background are distracting. 6
edit to add - one of the first pics I saw, then read the rules. Not much you can do about rotating, horizon line. bump to 7.