Fisherman's Wharf, Monterey Bay
by sfarrell23

Comment:
Really nice picture. I wish the focus of the picture would have leaned more towards the reflection though, the background which takes up about half of the picture is just way too busy and easily takes the attention away from the reflections.

Reflective Piano
by dtouch1

Comment:
Out of focus and extremely blown highlights which is easy to do when shooting from inside through a window. Normally I don't comment too much on blown highlights but since they are a major portion of the reflection and the reflection is the subject of this challenge I feel it really hurt this picture.

Freedom's Reflection
by photom1946

Comment:
Although you've captured an excellent reflection it is such a small part of this photo that it hardly stands out and is easily overpowered by the dimly lit building that doesn't do much for the eye.

Cambell's Lighthouse
by Dirtypainter

Comment:
I'm not sure if the orange in the bottom left was put in to add some color, tension or to fill in an empty area in the photo or because you couldn't get the reflection without having it sticking into the picture. I would prefer that it wasn't there as it distracts greatly from what should be the main subject of the photo, the lighthouse and then the beautiful trees.

Chesepeake Refelctions
by ewillison

Comment:
Picture needs more contrast and perhaps exposing one stop lower to allow for a deeper blue in the sky.

Glassware
by photobuddy

Comment:
Clean, crisp and an interesting reflection and subject, especially the spilled liquid. Minor issues for me are the tilted horizon, the seam in the surface on the top left edge, the dust spot on the sensor and those white squiggly lines in the standing glass kind of detracts from the perfect gradient. What are those squiggly lines anyway, something in the liquid or a reflection?

in the lake
by adeutsch

Comment:
It reminds me of one of those old paintings. The leaves floating in the water are annoying but not much you could do about that.

Baking
by SaraR

Comment:
What a wonderful idea and executed very well. The entire scene set up in the reflection really makes this one great.

Woody\'s Bookshelf
by emayner

Comment:
Blurry.

Cindy Woody, I think the red slipper fits!!!!!
by shutterbug8

Comment:
Woody is out of focus, did you intend this?