Ploughed Fields
by Ammie

Comment:
Reminds me of crop circles. Colors are beautiful and I like the composition very much, though I would have liked to have seen the tops of those distant hills. I find the image a bit soft, but I don't think that needs improvement. Gives it an abstract quality. Also, I think it would benefit from a border. Very well done. Bumping up to an 8.

Marsh Bridge
by temba

Comment:
Deep rich browns and greens are just exquisite. Lovely scene, and I love the rushing and still waters. Painterly. This is my favorite for the challenge, though not my highest scoring because it's not obviously HDR, though I believe it to be, and ironically, this may be its strongest point. Some may think it lacks a human presence (say fly fishing), but I believe it to be perfect as is. A timeless classic. Take a bow.

Train Mail
by cpanaioti

Comment:
Exquisite lighting and colors with a vintage feel that should get you a ribbon. Excellent clarity and detail. Masterful job. I love this!

Another Day in La Jolla
by jumboshrimp

Comment:
Lovely light and beautifully soft pastel colors. A lovely piece. Bumping up to a 9.

Changi Beach Sunrise
by andrewt

Comment:
This has got to be the winner. It's got the clarity, colors, good compositional design (great leading lines), detail in the shadows, yet an image that doesn't scream HDR and a beautiful sunset to boot. Just lovely! Bumping to a 10.

Mardis Mill Falls
by dswann

Comment:
While a nice photo with great clarity and good composition, I think it's going to fall short as an HDR and this may hurt your scoring. The highlights are very good, but the shadows are a bit too deep. Also your non-HDR processing in the foliage is a little too obvious. The biggest negative is the sky has no detail and looks really bad

Simplicity within a world of forced complexity
by liberty

Comment:
Sorry, I really can't see any HDR processing here. It's way too dark and the shadows are blocked up. It does have visual interest for me but I see this more as digital art than a photo. Wish I could have given you higher.

summering galaxies
by posthumous

Comment:
My guess is this is the fine work of Whiterook. If it is, you could have retitled the image Awesome Squirrel. Sorry, don't see the challenge theme expressed in your photo, (perhaps you interpreted HDR as high death rate?) so I had to drop your score from a 1 to a 2.

Il Duomo
by got2bgutsy

Comment:
Great detail and sharpness, but the composition and lighting is lacking.

Another Friday in San Francisco
by pjangel

Comment:
The voters really missed this one. Should have finished much higher. A gem.