Amaretto on the...
by qachyk

Comment:
I don't like the composition or viewpoint of this shot and the specular hightlight on the top of the bottle is very distracting. I think it would have been more effective had the bottle been laying on it's side with maybe some seaweed around to suggest it had been washed up on shore. I also think a close up of the bottle would have been better so that you don't see all those rocks. You've also lost detail in the top of the bottle which is as distracting as the highlight below it.

Go with the Flow
by marinajoe

Comment:
Very nice abstact design, I like the picture alot but I think it's a stretch to say it satisfies the challenge.

Ink Blot
by justine

Comment:
Nice detail in the pen. I think this could have been more effective if the pen were lying next to, instead of on top of, the ink blots, which kind of blends in with the dark blue of the pen.

Milk Bubbles in Oil
by Eliza

Comment:
I like the effect you've gotten here with the white milk on bottom and the blue bubbles on top. Also like the blue cast you've achieved but am not crazy about the way the milk is lit with it being bright on the left side and in dark shadow on the right. Maybe more diffuse lighting would have been better.

Refracted Honey
by shareinnc

Comment:
Nice abstract and I like the different yellow/gold tones here. Lots of noise but it doesn't detract from the shot.

Less Filling
by rickhd13

Comment:
I like the back lighting here and the gradient background here. Composition is not all that interesting though.

Paint
by loz1

Comment:
The shadow really makes this shot for me along with the red color of the paint, and I like the way the brush, bottle and shadow are all laid out here in an interesting arrangement of composition. I just think the lighting is too bright and the shadows should be darker. You may have been able to accomplish both by moving the light further from the bottle.

Always Refreshing, Always Coca-Cola!
by The Kid

Comment:
I wish the reflection in the glass of the bottle weren't there.

Sealing Liquid
by snowleopard10101

Comment:
Very nice colors and I like the cropping of the composition so that you can't see the tops of the bottles which creates a semi-abstract. Lighting may be a bit too harsh but it works here and I do find the lone label in the bottom right to be a little too distracting. But fine capture overall.

liquid chocolate
by miss parker

Comment:
You've really captured the color of the chocolate well and I like your idea here, but just find it not to be very convincing.