Blessed Bounty
by scarbrd

Comment:
congratulations - this photograph contains a fruit and/or a vegetable, therefore it meets the challenge! well done!

interesting view of the marketplace. but i think the shot is too wide to give us a clear subject. the background is a little distracting. 5!

Planet Peach
by pmichaud

Comment:
congratulations - this photograph contains a fruit and/or a vegetable, therefore it meets the challenge! well done!

i like the minimal framing, but i think it's a little too minimal. 6

wait
by bvlindalou

Comment:
not much in it though ... 0.01 at the end ... my score plummeted in the last hour.

but, as my original comment said, this is a great shot. congrats on the top 10 finish! :)

Emotional Outlet
by scalvert

Comment:
damn you scalvert!!!!

until an hour before this challenge finished, i had you ... I HAD YOU!!

still one of my favourite shots from the challenge though. well done mate!!

Sew Real
by toddhead

Comment:
this is a very, very clever photo ... i admit i had to look at it twice before i saw the silhouette. an outstanding composition. even though i don't think this is personification, i've still given you 10! :)

Post Mortem Examination
by samhall

Comment:
oh ... oh ... this is just terrible. i'm sorry but i don't have the stomach for this.

please don't be offended, but i think this is in rather poor taste.

Ivan The Terrible
by rinac

Comment:
this made me laugh ... great composition. i'd have changed the framing a bit, lowering the camera to crop out the ground (below the wall) but keeping the boy's feet in the shot. that's my only criticism - the bottom of the frame. perhaps also a bit brighter ...

but i liked this very much. 10 from me! :)

Bad Karma
by gloda

Comment:
one of my favourite shots in the challenge ... very creative photography. nicely done! 10!

It's good to be bad
by nsoroma79

Comment:
great photo!! i had a similar idea, but no way of photographing it. i gave this a 10!! good luck, i think you deserve a ribbon! :)

Living with Asthma
by talj

Comment:
technically it needs work ... i think the lighting is a bit off ... more detail is needed on the asthma apparatus and perhaps a black shirt to prevent the blown highlights.

but i think the composition is good ... use of the frame is very, very good. the tube comes in from the bottom corner very nicely and the negative space works well to draw attention to the subject.

to be honest, i think you've under processed this shot because it's a self portrait ... i think that comes from a reluctance or fear to express yourself. adding a little more light and sharpness to the shot would make the world of difference.

overall, a very good shot ... and quite an impact! 8!