Forgotten Path
by insteps

Comment:
Very dark, needs a stop or two on the exposure

We have separation
by patman49

Comment:
need to make the horizon flat - feels wierd like this

Irony
by Pazreal

Comment:
Oh my god is that for real?
Fantastic irony ;-)

B&W Composition - Fallen roadsign on isolated lane, Shottle, Derbyshire
by Richie23

Comment:
I know where this is. I used to wrok in Belper, just down the road ;-)

Aperture
by Zoomdak

Comment:
Gold ribbon, not just blue. A most beautiful shot, my gongratulation on the image and the impending win.

Ice Candle Volcano
by poeticphoto

Comment:
Feels way too oversharpenned, I've no idea what I'm looking at

3 lamps in a narrow port
by visaksen

Comment:
I wondered about this one. Almost like a scene from star wars. Then I realised what it actually is. Excellent, not many people look up ;-)
Great work - 7 (there arn't many getting above 7 from me in this challenge!)

Pronged
by Konador

Comment:
Hmmm, strange one this. I can't say theres anything wrong with it as such, it just doesn't take me to the WOW zone. Its like half a step off that.

Having said that its way better than the majority in this challenge, Has to be in the top 30-40 or so for me. The background is what pulls this up from the croud.

Babyhood, Childhood, Adulthood
by eaglebeck

Comment:
Please do go to the tutorial about resizing for submission. Thumbnail size submissions will always get a 3 or 4 from me, no matter how good or bad the image is, and its so easy to resize to 640 pixels on the long edge.

As for the image, well the bottles, yep meets the challenge, but look at how you have arranged them - flat accross the fram. Theres endless possibilities for a little more dynamic setup here, especially if you are willing to play with the lighting too

Three is a CHARM
by melster

Comment:
I'm sorry, I have a real problem with this image. First of all it shows 4 attachments, OK 3 are heads and one is a heart I'll accept that. My main problem though is that its so dull. there;s nothing to keep my attention, no artistry, no WOW Compositionally it hasn't been thought through. I'm sorry if that offends in any way, but its my honest thoughts.

Now how could we have made this something more appealing. How about having the chain on a nice pretty wrist, with a beautiful out of focus sunny/snowy/background, something like the winners of the Bokeh challenge produced. Or even have the bracelet being carressed by a pretty face. There are so many other ways of presenting this than on a plain old pullover.

Hope some of that might have helped, thats the way it was intended.