Let's go!
by dimitrii

Comment:
"Critique Club Comment"

COMPOSITION- The way you have placed everything is good. I like that you've filled the frame and don't have a whole lot of extra space in the shot. You could have cropped just a little less to get the whole bag in.

BACKGROUND- it is white

CAMERA WORK- Your exposure is great.

DIGITAL PROCESSING- you've compressed this good and your levels seem fine.

MY OPINION- I thought this photo was just average during the voting. I think it would have a little more impact if you would have the hand holding the passport and more in focus. Or what I think would be neat if you could have slowed down the shot and had the hand taking the passport out of the bag.

Weeeee!
by Frank Beckman

Comment:
"Critique Club Comment"

COMPOSITION- Composition is pretty good. I like that you don't have the girl centered in the middle of the photo and more space in front of her. It gives the feeling of going somewhere. The angle you used also is very good. I think the photo would have been a little more powerful if you had her looking the way she is going and both hands on the rope instead of waving.

BACKGROUND- Background is a little busy with all the houses. More impact could have been had if you used a bigger aperature to blur them out more. Also what I think would have been neat would have been to use a slightly slower shutter speed and pan with her to get a motion effect.

CAMERA WORK- your exposure is great on this. My only thought is to slow the shutter to give more of a sense of motion.

DIGITAL PROCESSING- Your compression on this is great. No artifacts.

MY OPINION- I think this was a nice shot. Fits the challenge great.

Ice
by lumbus

Comment:
This is great. Perfect shutter speed. I love waterfall photos.

Endurance
by bobgaither

Comment:
"Critique Club Comment"

COMPOSITION- Beautiful composition. It is framed well with just enough below and above. Great color and nothing too distracting. Reflections are great.

BACKGROUND- Nothing super distracting in it. The boats in the background are perfect. The clouds look really neat. They look kind of painted into the sky.

CAMERA WORK- Great DOF and Shutter speed. Everything is sharp and nice. A polarizor might have been nice to bring out more blue in the water and sky.

DIGITAL PROCESSING- done great, no compression or the like.

MY OPINION- This is a beautiful shot. It fits travel nicely, on the water. I like the reflection. For some reason water shots are usually my favorite, I just like rushing water or any type of water.

DAYS OF WINE AND ROSES
by falvey

Comment:
very creative and nice effect

Smoke on the Water
by inspzil

Comment:
Great night shot and colors. This is pretty. It looks like it needs rotated about 1 or 2 degrees clockwise.

Who let the dogs out? Who?
by justine

Comment:
this is hilarious. I wish you would have done some fill flash or used a separate light so there wouldn't be any harsh shadows. This is great though. I love it.

The Rose
by autool

Comment:
great detail in this shot. It seems a little overexposed or too contrasty, I don't know it just feels misty.

Lake Genesis
by MagsCoyote

Comment:
beautiful rich colors. Your shot is suffering from major compression. Try to save it as close to 150K as you can. It is a beautiful shot.

rush
by FranziskaLang

Comment:
he only has one leg!. I like how only one is in focus and the rest is blurred.