Aquae
by colorosilence

Comment:
I like the texture, reflections and overall shape of this a lot. Compositionally, I think the black diagonal on the left is unwanted, and I would consider maybe rotating this to make the water diagonal to the frame. Other forms of cropping might work well too. Nice work.

Winter Wonderland
by spiller

Comment:
This is a very lovely scene. The exposure is just right.

Water & Ice
by oskar

Comment:
Actually, I think I prefer your outtake (the one from the forums), but still, this is a very nice picture, and I'm sure you will do well with it = )

Freezing along the way...
by timmi

Comment:
One of my favorites of the challenge. The colors are great, really gives a cold feeling to the image. I think the one big "thing" of ice (kinda looks like an inverted mushroom) takes a way slightly from the flow of the rest of the ice. Still, great job. -9-

Walking on Water
by puya

Comment:
Lovely colors in the sky. I also like how the surf flows to and from each side of the image, nice composition. I think I'd actually like it better without the people in it, but I understand that probably wasn't possible.

Winter Creek
by Firstrich1

Comment:
The water color looks a bit unnatural, but the saturation looks pretty good on the grass and the foliage. I think toned down a little (color), this would be a great shot. -7-

48 Months of Debt Smiling at Me
by Maverick

Comment:
Thanks for the comments. I'm not sure I understand the lack of sharpness comments, it looks sharp to me. That said, this is pretty much the vote I expected. The grill is stock, actually.

For a college student with only a co-op (similar to an internship) for income, a new car is a big investment. The car is my "baby" ; ) So far I'm very happy with it.

Prospecting
by Antithesis

Comment:
Where is the prospecting? Having someone panning in the river would do well to tell the story without the title here. It is a lovely scene, but depends completely on the title to relate to money.

Spend Here!
by melongrind

Comment:
I like the idea of taking a picture of a shop window, but there really isn't much of interest in this window. It looks like a shoe store based on the background, - a more glamorous (ie, pricey) store window might get the point across a little better.

Rebus
by jvanderau

Comment:
lol, very interesting. creative interpretation of the challenge. Seems a little low in contrast, maybe playing with levels and such would give more life to the subjects.