Illusion
by fordmanf1

Comment:
Challenge: SHADOWS III
Description: Creatively capture a shadow
Advanced Edit
Illusion
Fit: Clearly meets the challenge 1

Aesthetics: OK composition 1
But does it creatively capture a shadow? Not sure to be honest
Technical: Technically well executed 2

Wow: Has some impact 1
Doesn't creatively capture a shadow for me, although the photo is good in its own right
Total Score = 5

Morning Wake-Up Juice!
by FotoMunki

Comment:
Challenge: SHADOWS III
Description: Creatively capture a shadow
Advanced Edit
Morning Wake-Up Juice
Fit: Clearly meets the challenge 1

Aesthetics: Well composed, aesthetically pleasing 2
Somehow this sums me up in the morning, sans les sucre
Technical: Technically well executed 2
A little stark maybe but effective none the less
Wow: Has some impact 1
Interesting without being "out there"
Total Score = 6

Extreme Shadow Puppets
by Nobody

Comment:
Challenge: SHADOWS III
Description: Creatively capture a shadow
Advanced Edit
Extreme Shadow Puppets
Fit: Epitomises the idea behind the challenge 2
Very clever indeed
Aesthetics: Well composed, aesthetically pleasing 2
I like thw ay the eye is drawn from the figure to the shadow and then half down to the open shuttered window
Technical: Technically well executed 2
Maybe it lacks a little detail in the figure?
Wow: Has some impact 1
A good picture that just feels a little flat - and I am not sure why.
Total Score = 7

Shadow Dining
by graphicfunk

Comment:
Challenge: SHADOWS III
Description: Creatively capture a shadow
Advanced Edit
Shadow Dining
Fit: Epitomises the idea behind the challenge 2
Took me a while to get this one
Aesthetics: Well composed, aesthetically pleasing 2
The straightforward contradiction between the still life and shadow make this fun
Technical: Technically well executed 2
Nice capture of the colours and tones in the still ife.
Wow: Has some impact 1
Just feel that this may be a little too subtle for the 10 second brigadeâ€Â¦
Total Score = 7

The Wall
by MrXpress

Comment:
Challenge: SHADOWS III
Description: Creatively capture a shadow
Advanced Edit
The Wall
Fit: Clearly meets the challenge 1

Aesthetics: OK composition 1
The shadows are there and acts as frames to the wall, and the wall textures are well observed.
Technical: Technically well executed 2
Feel that a little more detail in the shadows would have helped this.
Wow: Has some impact 1
Just lacks punch overall.
Total Score = 5

Reflective Light
by sherpet

Comment:
Challenge: SHADOWS III
Description: Creatively capture a shadow
Advanced Edit
Reflective Light
Fit: Epitomises the idea behind the challenge 2
This is a very creative capture of a very complex shadow
Aesthetics: An exceptional composition/exceptional aesthetics 3
This is a really well balanced and harmonius composition to me. The parallelism in the vase and shadow, the ellipse captures at the union of th two and the softness of the background compliment the colours and the shadow dynamics.
Technical: Technically well executed 2
Maybe - just maybe - a little more DOF as the neck of the vase seems a little out focus?
Wow: Slaps you in face 3
There is just so much to like about this image.
Total Score = 10

Monumental
by bryanbrazil

Comment:
Challenge: SHADOWS III
Description: Creatively capture a shadow
Advanced Edit
Monumental
Fit: Clearly meets the challenge 1
There is a shadow butâ€Â¦
Aesthetics: OK composition 1
I like the image and the use of B&W but feel that the shadow - th epoint of the exercise - has been lost a little in the image. Maybe a tighter crop loosing some of the foreground?
Technical: Technically OK 1
Real lack of highlight and shadow details for me
Wow: Has some impact 1
I actually like this as an image but feel that it does "creatively capture a shadow" - sorry
Total Score = 4

Shadowfly
by vtruan

Comment:
Challenge: SHADOWS III
Description: Creatively capture a shadow
Advanced Edit
Shadowfly
Fit: Clearly meets the challenge 1

Aesthetics: OK composition 1
I love the way the fly's shdow has been caught but it is lost in the vast expanse of the leaf. Maybe a tighter, portrait crop would help?
Technical: Technically OK 1
It seems as though the area of the leaf where the fly is is out of focus and there is a lack of DOF around the fly
Wow: Has some impact 1
Brilliant idea that would have scored higher if the DOF, focus and crop had been tighter
Total Score = 4

High Noon Shadows
by charleyangel

Comment:
Challenge: SHADOWS III
Description: Creatively capture a shadow
Advanced Edit
High Noon Shadows
Fit: Clearly meets the challenge 1
The compressed shadow from the midday sun is well observed
Aesthetics: OK composition 1
I cannot help but feel that the image would have had more impact with a toghter crop around the main subject, pulling the shadow into the front row.
Technical: Technically OK 1
The highlights are badly blown for me but there is a sense where this adds to the impact of the shadow.
Wow: Has some impact 1
By pulling the shadow more into the composition I think that this image would have significantly increased my score.
Total Score = 4

The Evil Inside
by stare_at_the_sun

Comment:
Challenge: SHADOWS III
Description: Creatively capture a shadow
Advanced Edit
The Evil Inside
Fit: Clearly meets the challenge 1
I am not sure that it does but there is a shadow!
Aesthetics: OK composition 1
It is moody for sure, but not evil. The shadows do not add to the image and it feels as though it could have been cropped tighter
Technical: Technically well executed 2
I cannot see much wrong with the technical aspects
Wow: Not special/ordinary 0
While I love the moodiness there is not much about this image that creatively captures a shadow, hence the low score - sorry.
Total Score = 4