Fingering Ghost
by kiwiness

Comment:
I'm not sure how this was done, I'm guessing you used some photoshop (perfectly legal) but it is REALLY COOL! This just looks awesome... and I'm hoping you'll tell us how you got this at the end of the challenge. I'm going to go with a 10 just beccause I think it's a really cool thing, and well shot.

Slickrock Sunrise
by dsidwell

Comment:
This looks similar to colors of both rocks and lighting, as well as shadows that I saw and photographed in Australia... is it Australia? I like the nice warm colors here... Polarizer? I also like the shadow coming in from the bottom left hand corner.

The Duck Hunter/Senior Portrait
by boyte1

Comment:
Good idea... but I think you need to use more of the light you have.. currently the light draws me to his pants, not up to his face.. also I think this could have used a much tighter crop I like his pose though... andd great smile :-). Hope he likes them!

Leftovers
by casualguy

Comment:
Great job with the exposure of the snow... it looks so nice and crisp, good packing snow? :-) I like your composition hereNice leading lines etc. Nicely done... solid photo.

Nathan
by deemer

Comment:
Nice job with the DOF here... the colors in the photo look a bit muted but that doesn't bother me.. I think I would have liked to have seen this cropped quite a bit more... so that the background didn't take up quite so much of the frame... also I don't really feel the boy is doing anything particularly interesting that catcheds my attention.

Samuel
by Jacko

Comment:
Jacko? What a cute kid and a great photo! Love the choice of black and white... andd the white background is nice... I'm thinking maybe of having this cropped so that Samuel fills the frame leaving less white and more baby...

Winter on the Lake
by eweb

Comment:
Beautiful scene and great black and white (slight blue toning?) This is very pretty and nicely composed, although I think it might be nice to crop out just a bit off the top to just above the tallest branch and maybe slightly off the right to where that first y branch is, and the clone out the jutting out branch, but thats just an idea... very nice as is... foggy looking... -8-

Supacross
by tomlewis1980

Comment:
Nice close look at the rider, but I feel as though this isn't a very intense part of the ride, the expression on the boys face isn't particularly intense, his muscles are completely bunched up, there is not mud flying up in the air... it's almost too clean to be a really great sports photo. Facial expression is VERY important for sports, but also the sense of the moment rather then just the clearest photo of any point in the race.

Patience...
by kosmikkreeper

Comment:
Great lighting and very eerie looking scene here. Definitely puts you on edge, and makes you feel a little nervous about what is happening... I think I might have framed it a little more with the picnic table in the right hand corner, but I do like the black upper right... interesting, and artsy.

co-op creamery
by undieyatch

Comment:
I don't really find a lot of interest in this photo. I think that you are trying to show the dilapidated building? but I'm not positive. Nothing really stands out here from everything else... might have been interesting to do it in portrait style with the door in possibly the bottom left corner or something like that, I just don't feel any part of this picture grabs me at all.