Water Play
by photochild405

Comment:
The boy is stationary so I don't get the feeling of motion panning here.

Skiing
by mannjudit

Comment:
As everything is in focus I don't really get the feeling of motion panning here. Have to say the snow looks really nice there!

Subway Blur
by ARMY_DOC

Comment:
As the subject is not moving this doesn't really fit in to the challenge description, I like the image though and the shadow of the lady on the train really adds to the photo, if she was standing even closer I think it would make it better.

White Women Can Jump!
by arnit

Comment:
Really like to know how you have done this....is it will a filter with a blurred edge or pure motion panning, I'm guessing a mixture of the two. Lovely image however it was taken!

Jump
by DAWAR

Comment:
There is no background so it is hard to gauge the speed of the jump and as the subject is so out of the focus, this looks more like an abstract that a motion panning technique

Some one just read my mind!!!
by charales

Comment:
Interesting idea, however I can't see motion panning being used here, as the background is in focus and the can is moving. The description of the challenge would help you here. There is something I don't get though as the blur is on the left of the can as well as the right? Hopefully you've put a nice description in the submission....

Golden Lights
by floydrowe

Comment:
That is a beautiful photo, however motion panning isn't used to achieve the effect. I like the soft colours and the sharpness of the image though.

Closer to the Heart
by Cam

Comment:
It's the inside of a pepper! interesting closeup, needs a touch more light though and unfortunately doesn't hit the challenge perfectly

Smell the Shade!
by usia

Comment:
This really isn't abstract photography, a lot of people appear to have confused abstract with macro, unfortunately this doesn't meet either. In terms of the photo, it is pretty good, the out of focus glasses aren't exactly pleasing to the eye, however it does make you think about the photo

Destination Unknown
by SDW

Comment:
a good strong architectural photo, that doesn't meet the challenge description.