Sunset at the dock
by jgirl57

Comment:
Hello from the critique club...

Stunning image.... I liked it very much. I absolutely love the clouds. Even though the image is a bit dark there is still plenty of detail. I am also a fan of the rays from the sun. Good job. I definitely think this shot was under rated. Happy shooting

into darkness
by posthumous

Comment:
Hello from the critique club...

Don...I do like this b&w...I'll start with the bad and then move to the good. I feel that the pic is too dark. That may have been what you were trying for though. I feel especially the trees on the left have lost tons of detail. However I do like the trees on the right. You can see detail there. Also I really like the clouds. The bridge is also interesting and looks good in the shot. Happy shooting

Two Shots At Every Pedestrian
by Dr.Confuser

Comment:
Hello from the critique club...

Interesting shot. It almost feels like a field of signs. I think overall well done. I like the sky. The scene has plenty of detail. Really nothing much more to say about it. I think you scored nicely. 5.5 isn't too bad. Happy shooting

bending the rules !
by sanandan

Comment:
Hello from the critique club...

Very interesting concept. However it seems that some of the colors are wrong. This could be due to lighting. It appears that this is a bright and sunny day. Sometimes that can make the colors fade. This shot definitely works well for the challenge. Good luck on your next image. Happy shooting.

Flights away
by otto22

Comment:
Hello from the critique club...

Your shot did quite well in voting. Any day you score over 6 is a good day. I really like this shot. The DOF is great. The colors are good. Very nice bird. You have captured plenty of detail in the bird and the wooden fence post. Your crop is also good. Overall good shot. Happy shooting

p l u m a g e
by Ja-9

Comment:
Hello from the critique club...

Janine...You have taken yet another beautiful shot. There is tons of detail in the feathers. I like the vibrant colors of the peacock. And your crop is nice. Another stunning image. Good job. happy SHOOTING

Under the bridge
by gmink

Comment:
Hello from the critique club...

Interesting concept. There are nice leading lines that draw the eye through the shot. However, there are some issues that pop out at me. The lighting is a bit harsh for me. I am talking about the two lines of light in the foreground. I think that is a bit distracting. Lighting can be a very tricky thing to control. Happy shooting

Alexander Calder Sculpture
by clickodak

Comment:
Hello from the critique club...

I like this b&w. It's a nice pic of a very interesting sculpture. There is plenty of detail to draw the eye. Also your crop is very nice. The sculpture is positioned well in the shot. Overall very nice job. Happy shooting

Laughter
by Ja-9

Comment:
Hello from the critique club...

Overall nice picture. The colors are crisp and clean. It very definitely portrays a very happy kid. However the crop is not working for me. I would have liked to see his entire head. The left and right sides are cropped just right. Overall I like this/ The subject is great. It really brings a smile to my face. Good job. Happy shooting

fido's leafball
by sidpixel

Comment:
Hello from the critique club...

Interesting shot. The unintentional thing that has happened here is the subject is no longer the plant....it's the guy and dog. I like the DOF. the plant is crystal clear with lots of detail. Very nice. The colors are as they should be. Personally I don't know why it scored so low. I would have given it a better score but unfortunately I did not vote in this challenge. I think job well done and happy shooting.