Liverpool Anglican Cathedral
by TonyUK

Comment:
Unbelievable. Fantastic capture. Have you thought about publishing these?

Liverpool Anglican Cathedral
by TonyUK

Comment:
Amazing work! I would love to see you add your work flow in the Photographer's comments above. That way you can share your expertise - imho, you certainly have perfected the art.

You are Now Free to Roam About the Country
by DrAchoo

Comment:
Amazing shot - where is PDX? Looks like it could have been taken down the road from where I live - at Skyharbor PHX. I love how you captured color in this shot too. I didn't get to vote in this one but it deserves the high score it received.

Bountiful
by Arcanist

Comment:
Great capture - the framing and backdrop makes the image pop.

The Promise of Bread
by brownsm

Comment:
I love this shot - reminds me of my mother so many years ago.

Long Before Sliced Bread
by senor_kasper

Comment:
Great photograph - you captured the essence of a time past. The lighting, setup and focus is great - 10

Low key hobby
by Melethia

Comment:
Deb, I definately think this is a low key shot. I think some of the voters think low key is black and white - which the majority of the top scorers submitted. Not taking away from any of those excellent shots, I believe you equally captured a creat low key shot. I see your rule of thirds in this too. I didn't vote in this challenge, but would have scored this very high - 9. Thanks for sharing.

A view from St Sauveur in Canada
by albc28

Comment:
Anthony, I didn't vote in this challenge, but appreciate what you were going for here. You certainly captured trees in this shot and for that it met the challenge in my opinion. I am guessing it didn't score higher because the picture is so broad in content. The subject doesn't speak 'trees' - while they are everywhere in your shot, there are other subjects too. I will say this though, no matter how broad the shot, I don't believe this is a sub 5 shot. Thanks for sharing.

Companions
by pamelasue

Comment:
Pam, this shot is definately not sub 5 material in my opinion. I didn't vote in this challenge, but I am guessing it lost points in the framing of the shot. Your horizon if tilted down from right to left - although that may very well have been your intent. Also, the gravestone in front is cut off a little at the bottom. I can't see how you could have cropped out the other trees without it cutting into your subject itself. The tree certainly creates a silhouetted effect you were going for. Thanks for sharing.

Junipalm
by GeneralE

Comment:
Paul, i think this picture should have scored higher than 5.1. You certainly met the challenge. Maybe it is how you framed it so centered. I think the blue sky behind the tree (palm) is stunning and even the bird in the upper right adds to the life of the picture.