Christmas Sky
by PGerst

Comment:
This shot seems very soft on focus and is tilted to the left. Be sure and check your horizons when you shoot or when you post process the shot. And be sure and check your focal point for clarity.

Pelican Lake - always a beautiful sky!
by rjackpine

Comment:
I'm seeing alot of noise in the sky of this. Not sure whats causing it but it takes away from an otherwise beautiful shot.

To the Light
by Geee

Comment:
This is a nice landscape. But there is something in the clouds and the sky that take away from it. I can see pixelation perhaps from shadow/highlights, or saturation problems otherwise its a nice image. 6

SFV from Afar
by funny pie

Comment:
This appears to be a simple snapshot with no use of HDR at all. There are no details in the shadows. THe dynamic range is small and the photo is rather flat. WIth some PP this could be a decent image though. The composition and subject are nice and have potential.

LA Story
by Germaine

Comment:
This is a fairly good example of what can be done with HDR. However the subject is pretty plain, and uninteresting. Its also way too busy. I cant find anything of interest as a main focal point.

My Little Devil Girl
by Judi

Comment:
This is cute. But not really an HDR shot as per the challenge. The dynamic range of this photo is rather small. You need deep shadows brought out and bright highlights with detail to get an HDR image. This looks like a simple snapshot. Goodluck.

Sunset at the old farm
by NstiG8tr

Comment:
You have met the challenge of HDR fairly well. It seems nicely processed and yet not over the top. You have brought the dynamic range out well in this photo. This is a 6 from me. I think this would have scored higher but something just doesnt sit well with me about the composition. I'm not sure what maybe its the straight on shot I'm not sure. I will try to comment further after more time to think. Good luck.

Late Afternoon
by Shy Clicker

Comment:
This is a 6 from me. The image while generally pretty seems somewhat flat especially for an HDR. The shadows dont have the details brought out and the only thing with good coloring is the sky and it may be over done just a touch. I"d liked to have seen you bring the Dynamic range way out on this photo for this challenge. The shadows in the mountains could have really been brought out with alot of detail. Good luck.

Light from Above and a Perch for Resting
by freakin_hilarious

Comment:
6 from me. You seem to have met the challenge well. I'm not fond of the composition. It leaves me wondering what the rest of the building looks like. Overall the colors are nice, however the coloring in the steeples and roof blue, look very unnatural and grainy. Good luck. Fairly good balance between shadows and highlights.

HDR in Providence
by valkner

Comment:
This got a 6 from me. I thought you did a nice job meeting the challenge of HDR. I can detail in shadows and highlights. I'm not fond of the perspective or the tall crop. But thats likely just a personal thing with me. The coloring of the sky is nice. Good luck.