Going Down?
by Davenit

Comment:
1)Does it fit the theme?(9)
2)Color(7)
3)composition(8)
4)Focus(7)
5)Background(8)
6)Lighting(7)
7)Title(7)

Total Score:(7.57 rounded to 8.0)

Commentary:
The idea here is wonderful. Exectution was great. One thing wrong with this picture that I can see and I do not know if it is my monitor or not, but I think I can see pixels. Other than that this is something i would hang on my wall. Good job.

John (TurboTech)

Toronto
by mapgem

Comment:
1)Does the Photo fit the Theme? (5)
2)Color(3)
3)Composition(2)
4)Focus(2)
5)Background(4)
6)Lighting(3)
7)Title(4)

Overall Score: (3.28 rounded to 3)

There appears to be some stuff wrong with this photo. Yes it depicts "Motion", but my oppinion is in a good Motion picture you have something that is still. That helps the viewer take note that there is motion in the Photo. That also helps to add an element of 3D to a 2 dimensional image. This should be the main goal of a photographer. Espeecially Landscapes.
Overall Score.

Going with the Flow
by spiderman

Comment:
1)Does the Photo fit the Challenge?(5)
2)Color(5)
3)Composition(6)
4)Focus(4)
5)Background(5)
6)Lighting(6)
7)Title(6)

Overall Score: (5.28 rounded to 5)

Sorry to be harsh on the score. I think there is a bit too much water here. I am wondering what this would have looked like a little wider angle. The composition is good. For some reason it looks a bit Pixilated.

John (TurboTech)

Subway
by stephan

Comment:
1)Does the Photo Meet the Challenge?(8)
2)Color(7)
3)Composition(7)
4)Focus(7)
5)Background(8)
6)Lighting(6)
7)Title(8)

Overall Score: 7.28 rounded to 7

This is a wonderful shot. For the lighting that you had to work with, I think your colors turned out Nicely. Is there any way for you to do custom white balance here. If not then disregard. It just has an unatrual Hue to the overall lighting. Other than that great shot.

How to Scramble an Egg
by indigo997

Comment:
1)Does the photo fit the Theme? (9)
2)Color(7)
3)Composition(8)
4)Focus(8)
5)Bacground(8)
6)Lighting(7)
7)Title(6)

Overall Score: 7.57 rounded to 8

Commentary:
This shot is done very well. I think the nail could have been straight. The idea is just perfect. The black background causes for the perfect amount of contrast here. Wish I would have used a black background myself. Wonderful shot

John (TurboTech)

Time In Motion
by kposey

Comment:
Does the Photo fit the Challenge (5)
Colors(6)
Composition(4) Cut half clock out. :-(
Focus(6)
Background(4)
Lighting (4) slightly harsh.
Title(4)

Overall Score (4.71) rounded to 5

Snow, Sleet & Freezing Rain
by Diana

Comment:
Does the Photo fit the Challenge (6)
Colors(5)
Composition(5)
Focus(4)
Background(5)
Lighting (4)
Title(3)

Overall Score: (4.57 rounded to 5.0)

Still and Speedy Steel
by takethat

Comment:
Does the Photo fit the Challenge (6)
Colors(5) think the white balance is off
Composition(6)
Focus(5)
Background(6)
Lighting (5)
Title (6)

Overall Score: (5.57 rounded to 6.0)

Gliding Swan
by icemarn

Comment:
This is a quality closeup.
Title:(7)
Color:(6)
Composition(7)
Focus(6)
Background(7) Beyond control
Lighting(6)
Does the Photo Fit the Challenge? (5)

Overall Score (6.28 rounded to 6.00)

I've Got it!
by sulamk

Comment:
1)Does the Photo fit the Challenge? (5)
2)Color:6
3)Composition:6
4)Focus:(5)
5)Background(5)
6)Lighting(6)
7)Does the Title fit the picture? (4)

Overall Score=5.28 Rounded to 5

This dog is not playing fetch as to what I cna see it look. Looks like he is being frightened by this other dog.