Ice Cream Social
by sibeling

Comment:
I LOVE this one. The Black and White really adds to the feel of this one... I love the booth cutting through the picture, it effectivley removes distraction and provides great contrast to the black of the windows.
The extra chair is a little unsettling, blocking off the women on the left. I wonder if the picture would be better off without it, but at the same time, it does add something too.
If this was an advanced editing challenge I would expect that you'd get rid of the horizontal lines in the near booth (what is that, anyway) and the spot of light (flash?) in the window.
Overall GREAT JOB!

'pure bliss'
by suemack

Comment:
A good shot of childhood bliss. The red really pops out, but I'm not sure if the green on the left is distracting or good contrast. I like the duality of the melting ice cream and the fact the kid's in a zipped up jacket. Something about the kid's expression is a little troubling though, like eating the icecream is work, or hard, or something...

Milk Creature
by mahobbes

Comment:
For me, the lack of anything in clear focus is distracting. I understand abstract, but there should still be a focal point.