Nature's gold
by nico_blue

Comment:
*Critique Club*

Wow what a bright image! I think this is a prefect fit for the challenge and nice to see something different from the bunch. Excellent idea using oranges, other fruit would not have been nearly as bright or colorful. I think the composition of this shot is the best part. The only thing I would have played with a little is the placement of the oranges, not quite so centered for the two, maybe off more the the left or right. I am really glad you left the seeds in they add another element to the photo. The glow from the bottom orange is a nice complement to the the seeds and outside of the orange that are darker in the shot.

Windows
by flip89

Comment:
*Critique Club*

This is a ideal image for either the transparency contest or reflection. What an amazing place to see able to take this shot, I would have never guessed that this was a museum. I love the placement of where you took the shot from as well as the composition. The image seems so peaceful, possibly from all the blue. I also really like that you can sees a little sail boat out on the water as well as people outside the building. The only I would comment on is those small reflections in the windows in just a few small place. Overall I think you did a great job, people may have just voted it higher in the reflection category.

See-Through Silhouette
by owen

Comment:
*Critique Club*

What an eye catcher! I love the color. I also think like the other commentator that the guy in the image is happy, maybe its the warm yellow color but you just feel like he is having a good day. I really do also love the detail on the reflection, the rock and leaves are so great to see. The glow from what I think would be the clouds is so cool to see in the reflection as well. I really don't see anything I would recommend changing or altering. Excellent job!

Windshield
by Olyuzi

Comment:
*Critique Club*

This is a great shot, I love the warm colors and shine. The only thing is I like a few others are not sure of what it is. I think I understand that we are looking through an amazing windshield that show no reflection and possibly looking at a boat. The little shine or stars are so prefect they look like they were placed on the image afterward. Personally I think you scored lower on the image because people did not know what they were looking at, I know that is what I thought. Its a bummer there is that one dark spot on the white space between the wiper and metal piece. Great angle and taking a different point of view from the basic run of the mill image. Good job on making us all think and question what we are looking at.

Hazy Morning
by postoakinversion

Comment:
*Critique Club*

Awesome job, this is a very well deserved finish. This was an extremely tough category in my opinion. It was really nice to see something different in this category as well. I love the warm feel in such a scenic farm town area. I don't see much of anything I would change. The only thing, very small is possibly is adjust the contrast to make the sky a little bluer or add a polarizing filter. You did an excellent job, congradulations!

I can almost see it!
by zapgrafx

Comment:
*Critique Club*

What an interesting idea, great concept under the transparency category. I like that you were brave and put yourself out there, I think that is awesome. The subject is great, I love the combining of two subject like a woman and science. The first thing that hits me from the image is your shirt. The texture draws away from the subject just a little bit, I would have preferred a basic t-shirt either white or black. Also there seems to be a little bit of a line above your head on the left side, some one commented on possible window sill in the shot. I really love the warming feeling in the background color, it almost looks like a perfect backdrop. I think you did a great job I would have scored you higher then what you received. Good job.

Cutting The Cake
by Makka

Comment:
Amazing faces, great job on the capture. The pose is prefect in encompassing everything I would think the wedding couple would want. Great job on all of these.

Just Married!
by Makka

Comment:
Awesome black and white. I normally love color especially with her dress, but you did a prefect job on picking a great black and white.

A New Family
by Makka

Comment:
Very natural feel and look for a wedding photo. I might crop it a little just because of the odd shadow on the bottom left corner. These are really some of the better wedding photos I have seen.

Father & The Bride
by Makka

Comment:
I like the capture of father and daughter, I personally would like to have seen a little less on top and a little longer on the bottom. Of course I am a girl and we love dressed, maybe that why I would crop the top a little. Good job.