Narcissus
by salparadi

Comment:
I'm really not sure why there's all that black space at the bottom, but a tighter frame would definately help here. I like the middle shot, because the captured expression seems the most authentic, and it seems to be the most genuine representation of the person (who I'm guessing is you). Maybe instead of different expressions this could have been done with different zooms or angles instead. I do like the extreme contrast effect, and how you worked the background into it. The abstract result works well. 7 (mostly for the center frame)

Joy, Comfort, and Love
by dacrazyrn

Comment:
There's some interesting photoshop work here, but this still isn't a multi-image composition, it's just one image with some frames laid over it. However, I do like how each of the frames represents a different crop of the shot, each of which would be very effective (especially the top two). It's a good shot, but only by the farthest stretch of imagination does this fit the challenge. 4

Message edited by author 2003-05-05 09:00:25.

retired, but still attracting people
by kenbo

Comment:
The bottom two shots come across as cluttered.

Salt & Pepper
by severin

Comment:
A great concept, and a beautiful study in patterns of black and white. I think this shot would be helped greatly if all three frames were more crisp, as the salt/pepper shakers all seem to have too much blur to them. Nice work. 8

What color do you like?
by Pep Ventosa

Comment:
This is a very cool idea, and it's executed well.The different colors are very effective. I like how the images are progressive, but also overlap a bit. Nice work. 8

I Love you... this much!!!
by kosmikkreeper

Comment:
I like the creative idea with the arms cut out. I'm not sure why you desaturated everything but red though, as the color doesn't have any significant function here. Also, the facial expression doesn't do much for me. Good luck. 5

Pick On Someone Your Own Size!
by whitetiger

Comment:
The people (and staircases) provide a sense of scale that makes this shot immensely more effective. This shot made me think about how I can't even imagine a living one of those suckers.

Jeni's Etude
by sagestudio

Comment:
This was a good choice for a multi-image shot, because the right and left side shots are good shots, but without a context they would be hard to identify for someone not familar with the harp. However, the middle shot provides that context, and therefore makes the other shots more effective. Good work. 7

$peedVision
by RiderGal

Comment:
I like the tight crops on these. I think the result is more compelling than if they had been more revealing shots of the cars. Lets see how my identification skills are, I'd guess top to bottom: Lamborghini (Diablo), Jag (not sure about that one), and Ferrari (F50). I guess I'll see how I did after the challenge. 8

Day's End
by welcher

Comment:
the top and bottom images strike me as so-so, but that center image is really excelent. Great angle for the panoramic shot you got.