Squareway
by r_sandler

Comment:
I like the geometrical feeling very much. Your good composition / cropping makes it an interesting shot. I can't give any tips, how to make this one better, but somehow I'm missing something here...

Abstract
by stephan

Comment:
I like the colours here, meets the challenge very well too. A large reprint of this shot would be probably great in a modern furnished apartment. But I don\\\'t like this shot very much as a submission to a photography contest. I trust in you, that this shot is really a photo, but it looks more as computer art to me. Nevertheless a unique and outstanding submission. I changed my vote from 3 to 6 after coming back and thinking a 2nd time about it...

A Tajirian Square
by jwitt33

Comment:
Sorry, but I don't get the connection with the challenge title. Could have brought into a sharper focus too.

Eyes Sq On
by redfig

Comment:
A very creative interpretation of the challenge and a well done shot too. Perhaps I would have cropped a little different. IMHO the photo shows too much of the hand in the upper left corner. Overall it could be a little sharper too. Nevertheless a beautiful shot, I voted 8. Good luck!

Life inside the Frame
by arnit

Comment:
Congrats to this highly impressive shot! I really like the composition and the idea with the frame around her face. The width of this frame is harmonising perfect with the border of your photo. Only one single mistake I saw after 2-3 minutes: There is a hard shadow in the top of her face, caused by the frame. Nevertheless an outstanding awesome shot and my only 10 this week. Good luck!

Yellow & Green
by svital

Comment:
Wow, a very creative idea! The yellow paper and the green eye are working good together. But IMHO there is some space for improvement too. You should have used some powder to eliminate / decrease the shine around the eye. I also don't like the shadow of the paper above the eye and the eye could have been brought into a sharper focus. Nevertheless great idea, good luck for the challenge!

Artificial Heart
by nds

Comment:
Thanks a lot to all of you for taking the time for a comment. Special thanks
to Arjen, who came back for a really nice comment after the challenge. As I
wrote already in my photo details, you can see here a german "no trespassing"
road sign. They are normally round. But this one seems to be a little bit older.
Over the years it was twisted by the growing tree. And from this angle it looks
like a "Artificial Heart".

Personally I am now in complete agreement with the comment of timwatts. The
adjustment of contrast by the post-processing is a little overdone.


@ Mr. Wheeler: Why did you comment "off topic"???

Circle of squares
by vjoz

Comment:
Very nice, I really like your shot. The eye of the viewer is guided immediately by the reflections to the squares on the manhole cover. Good eye to catch this! Perhaps I would have cropped a little smaller. There are some distracting objects on the top and the right side. Apart from it the composition is perfect. Good luck for the challenge...

Subtle Square
by BJ

Comment:
Nice still life, I like the unobtrusive colouring very much. Unfortunately this shot is completely out of focus. Perhaps this is a part of your composition and well considered. But IMHO it works not very well. Nevertheless good luck for the challenge!

Private road only.....
by kiwiness

Comment:
Verbieten verboten ;-) - prohibitions prohibited