Choose one !
by Hycind

Comment:
Oh wow. I like this. Simple, colorful, and eye catching. 8

Birth of a Planet
by caba

Comment:
I'm not totally certain what I'm looking at, but it's interesting. Composition: 6, distracting dust that could have been cleaned off: -1. Total: 5

Winter comfort
by lakritstroll

Comment:
Nice color composition. I think if you diffused your light to remove the harsh reflections, you'd have a great image. 6

Ran Out of Ideas
by Karchie

Comment:
I can't figure out what it is, so it's difficult to rate. I think if the entire image was in sharp focus, there would be some texture to look at and the image would be pretty interesting. As it is, there's only the tiny ring in the center.

Convergence
by ldallek

Comment:
I think this one would be stunning in b&w.

Lights
by ofurpesi

Comment:
Too small, but the concept is nice. 6 for mood and composition, -1 for the size (it's truly too small to appreciate fully). 5

Swiss' Potato
by andrerusso

Comment:
It's a circle, all right, but I think there are several elements "wrong", in my opinion: (1) focus is on the rear of the photo, but the perspective makes the eye want to wander to the front, (2) The second plate is a distraction, (3) the table cloth is not a particularly appealing color, (4) the coloration/presentation/angle of the food is not particularly appealing.

All in all, I get the feeling this is a snapshot of something on a table, but I feel like a photo of food should include some level of pre-composition: back the shot out to include more table, arrange some attractive elements around the plate (fork, cloth napkin, glass), etc.

Yo Yo Yo...
by norcalsnoe

Comment:
I feel like the lighting is a bit "dull" on this. Everything appears a little gray and lifeless. I think if you had a littel better lighting with some diffusion (the reflection in front of the yoyo) this could be a great photo.

Tuscan Sun
by pelf

Comment:
Beautiful. One of my favorite kinds of circles.

Big Circles and Little Circles and...
by chesire

Comment:
Truly, I think this would have been a stunning shot if it was in better focus and/or had some USM. The thumbnail caught my attention, but unfortunately, the larger image reveals the focusing flaws. Great idea, you should work on this one until you perfect it.