"Escalator"
by Barry

Comment:
I love the concept. Perhaps crop to remove the distracting yucky wall and rotational display?

Breakfast
by eugene

Comment:
The reflection is perfect. I'm not sure about the composition or the lack of an interesting background - could you have positioned the toaster at an angle, or further from the background, and still gotten as good a reflection? Bumping to a 7.

say cheese!
by agesz

Comment:
Thank you for no saliva! I love the concept. just wondering if it wouldn't be slightly nicer if cropped for a) showing the full lips, and b) showing no nostrils.

Liberty Resurrected
by zoolander

Comment:
I think you would have been much better off cropping out the bar (or whatever it is) at the bottom. Although there is metal in this shot, it looks (maybe my monitor?) like the cross is wooden, and since that's the focus of the image I'm having a hard time relating this to the challenge. The sky seems a little blown out as well.

Metallic
by Michaels

Comment:
I'm afraid that this (and the other tinfoil entries) diesn't work well for me. I like the idea & the reflections, but the wrinkly tin foil is distracting & unattractive to me.

Stainless Slave
by nitronen

Comment:
I like the idea here, but it seems a little overexposed.

metalwood
by Motzerela

Comment:
I like the tones and the shallow DOF. I wish it were larger (which I'm sure you've heard!) and had a little more contrast.

Sunburst
by winggirl

Comment:
I'm sure you've heard about the size of the photo. Also, I would have preferred to have seen ideally a larger crop, so that the entire sculpture were included, or a smaller one, so that it looks less accidental.

Tinsel Teeth!
by buzzmom

Comment:
Sorry, good idea but the saliva is grossing me out. I would have liked to have seen it either straighter horizontally, or a bigger angle if that's what you were going for.

Coffee pots of metal
by Antonino

Comment:
There seems to be a green-blueish tint here that, deliberate or accidental, isn't helping the photo for me. I like the reflections in the items. It seems too staged because of the carpet.