Simple Grid
by amsmyth

Comment:
The soft spot in the middle of the shadows kind of hurts, expecially because its right in the middle.

Thinking of Death
by arnit

Comment:
You gotta quit using the same girl all the time. I think we're on to her by now. Share the ribbons too dude :) You've done some great work and they are deserved. This one, I'm not so wild about. Good luck to you all the same.

Three Little Jugs
by agwright

Comment:
Excellent. I think cropping a bit off the left side to make the jugs just a little bigger in the frame would've been my preference, but its very good like this. Well executed very clear shot. I'm guessing you are doing pretty well with this one. Nice work 8

Tranquility
by Everyday Renee

Comment:
The blue is a little bit grainy. My guess is oversaturated. Nice concept for the photo and well executed. I think I'd have cropped the top of this photo off and lost most of the blackness and other unrelated stuff from the top so I couldn't made the geese a little bit bigger in the frame. The colors are very good and really add a lot ot the mood of the shot. I just think they are a little oversaturated.

Pfluger Bridge
by Gordon

Comment:
Easily the best picture of the challenge that I've seen so far. If you could PS the flares off the lights on the center of the bridge, easily 10. as is, 9. And I think my congratulations on a ribbon might be a bit premature, but I haven't seen anything this good yet. This is stunning.

Pear and shadow
by alexbol

Comment:
The light is a little bit bright on the pair. I'd say just a tad overexposed, but nothing too major.

light, feather, shadow II
by ursula

Comment:
Nice toning. Good concept and very good execution. 8

Horton Plaza Shadows
by stuart

Comment:
blue looks very oversaturated

Waiting
by heida

Comment:
you might have pursued a black and white or sepia for this one. I think it would've enhanced the mood of the shot. I don't feel the color is an integral part of this shot and I wouldn't miss it if it was gone.

White shadow of captured freshness (in-camera effect)
by Louison

Comment:
I don't like the explanation of the photo in the title. Taking nothing away from the title though, this is a well executed and thought out photo. 8