Fired Ice
by fannyb

Comment:
THis needs to be bigger so we can see what's going on. the crop should be a little tighter too so there is minimal bare black space in the composition. Great subject for a macro tho

The Wind and the Waves
by BAMartin

Comment:
Good photo. I normally like the skies really blue, but the darker sky adds some contrast to the water. Needs something to provide a little more impact and give a definite focal point.

Fire, Flower (earth), and Water (and of course air!)
by Neil

Comment:
Title is too long. Looks like you have some little while specks around the bottom of the glass. The color added in is pretty vibrant but why not use a more colorful flower too? Just curious

unscheduled drydock
by timboydwhite

Comment:
Yucky sky never makes for good pictures. Framing was appropriate to minimize it, but it never goes away. Needs some color for visual impact.

Life on Earth
by pitsaman

Comment:
this seems just a little underexposed and maybe not lit quite as well as it could be. Good picture, but I think reaching a little for this challenge.

Water
by Dim7

Comment:
The front stuff in the middle to lower right is really compelling. Nice job exposing this properly and an all around good capture. This is a cool picture.

Reflections
by garrywhite2

Comment:
Your horizon seems to be running uphill a bit from left to right. The seagulls are too far away to make a case that they are part of the subject matter.

Black-tailed Earth Dog
by vtruan

Comment:
Well framed, for the size of the shot. The aspect ratio is a little strange it seems to me any way. But its a pretty nice job, especially with the framing of it.

Heat
by katlyn

Comment:
The large black area in the bottom right really throws the balance of this photo off and breaks the conitinuity established by the flame. Great colors and action in the flames. With something else on the bottom to add a little more interest and a little less plain black, I think you could get away with having something on the bottom.

Water
by jjbeguin

Comment:
Excellent reflections and patterns in the reflections. Nice job with this shot and good luck.