Jim Talin, Master Bookbinder
by Bear_Music

Comment:
His hand could have been posed better. It looks like a stump. The general rule is not to pose hands so the back or front is fully facing the lens.

Watching football
by Ragga2000

Comment:
wonderful 10

High strung
by caba

Comment:
I think you could have choosen a better angle.

Tony Roberts- 34 Years of Golf Photography
by oOWonderBreadOo

Comment:
wonderful

Julliet
by Pano

Comment:
Your light is to far to the side. The shadow from her nose and lips is distracting. You need to either raise the light up and move it closer you you or move it more to the side to get true side light so her whole side of her face is shadowed. Also the ratio of light to shadow is a little to high. You needed to bump up your fill light a little.

Officer Romain, At Your Service
by muur88

Comment:
Your color looks a little green on my screen. The photo itself is just wonderful. Not many people read the challenge very well. You did a great job.

Guardian:Companion ~ environment varies...follow the photographer
by glad2badad

Comment:
The challenge is to photograph the subject in an enviroment that says something about them. I am not sure if the flower field fits you dog. I don't know your dog, and it id definatly a beautiful portrait, but it doesn't say anything about him. Sorry

The Driver
by librodo

Comment:
just wonderful

Lighthouse Keeper
by Paige

Comment:
Beautiful shot, but I don't think is fits the challenge as well as it could.

Fisherman at work
by IceRock

Comment:
This is more journalistic than environmental portrait.