The Rocket's Blue Glare?
by GeneralE

Comment:
Not enough of the fireworks to make the picture interesting.

Man-Made Rainbows
by stickee

Comment:
Even in the most abstact of thinking I am not feeling this one at all.Sorry

Circle of Dreams
by RayEthier

Comment:
Out of Focus, Colors are not complimentary.

Summer Sparklers
by kaedemoon267

Comment:
too small, sorry just looks like a big mess to me.

Simple Shape, Simple Message
by Tallbloke

Comment:
over exposed and OOF

Flower
by olhobemaberto

Comment:
out of focus, way over exposed on the right side, colors are blah.

Lights
by ofurpesi

Comment:
too small and Out of Focus,

Happy Birthday
by gothgirl83

Comment:
Out of focus, but I hope Robert had a great birthday..

Duo Maxwell
by AmiYuy

Comment:
interesting picture but I am not seeing any circles...

Faltered
by CorySmith

Comment:
Hello from the Critique Club!!!

Composition:

I like the idea of the shot. I see the comments are all over the place but I am in the camp that there is just a tad too much red.

Camera Work:

DOF is shallow but it is not too distracting. Lighting works and adds to the shot. The only thing that really bothers me at all is the end of the petals. I am not sure why, they just make me stop and see what they are.

Post-Processing:

I can not comment on your post-processing because you did not include it in the comment field. Including this information helps us see what you have done, and can help teach other users how to use post processing to improve their pictures.

My Opinion:
I like the shot, it shows a very romantic side and one that any girl would love see waiting for her someday.
You are a very talented and I think your abilities and passion for this art will take you far. Keep shooting and sharing and teach us old dogs some new tricks

I hope you find these comments to be helpful, thank you for allowing me to critique your picture. If you have any questions or concerns feel free to contact me via PM.

Best of luck in your future photographic endeavors,

Regards,
Karen Doss