I'm stuck here doing housework while the wife's out bowling with the girls!
by Lorene

Comment:
Concept: Better than many, but does not translate well to challenge.
Execution: Nice and clean, good use of partial desat. Nice expression too.
Quality: Excellent, but lighting seems very flat.

( 4 )

The Never Ending War
by sickdog

Comment:
Concept: Better translation to challenge on common theme.
Subject: Not interesting. Crop too wide, distracting elements.
Image Quality: Snapshot, poor lighting, flat lighting.

( 4 )

Pats 21, San Diego 21...Turn the Channel
by tfarrell23

Comment:
Concept: Unique Twist on Common Idea. Translation to challenge: Not easily picked up without title of image. Image Quality: Excellent. Use of shallow DOF is brilliant.
Loss of major points for concept vs easy translation to challenge.

( 4 )

Eye of the Tigress
by elizadeb

Comment:
Concept: Common. Execution: Appears Contrived. (model's fault not photographer). Lighting: Seems flat, lots of noise in shadows.
Interest Level: As if it is a snapshot.

( 4 )

Arm Wrestling
by Art Roflmao

Comment:
Concept: Unique perspective on common concept.
Image Quality: Excellent although the lighting seems flat.
Interest Level: Little although redeemed by quality of image.

( 4 )

how we struggle
by chele

Comment:
Concept: Somewhat Common. Execution: Boring.
Image Quality: Lighting: Poor, muddy, not dynamic. Appears to be Over-NeatImaged. Skin appears plastic, and out of focus.

( 3 )

We're Not Late!
by nards656

Comment:
Concept: Fair. Does not translate battle of the sexes well at all.
Image quality: Fair, good focus, lighting dynamics: Fair
Subject matter: Boring.

( 4 )

I want to be what you are
by yianisn

Comment:
Concept: Excellent. Execution: Fair. Crop detracts immensely from this. A close up to rid the prop of the flat board covered with sheet would have raised the quality of this image a lot! Loss of a lot of detail in the shadows and the pose, covers too much of the action to make me realize immediately how much tooth really went into this image.

( 4 )

Marriage
by GueDesigns

Comment:
Concept: Better than some, almost unique.
Quality: Good focus.
Setup: seems contrived and not natural.
Lighting is flat, shadows could be avoided with backlighting.
Too many items spread out in the overall image to give it finesse.

( 4 )

Fighting for (the) control
by justamistere

Comment:
Concept: Common. Lighting: Poor, Flat
Image: Good focus, good crop, but lacks interest.

( 3 )