Tree
by mkirdal

Comment:
Composition: 4, Fairly static. Maybe placing the tree of the left and balancing it with the person on the right would help
Technical: 4, Middle greys are very dominant. Stretching tone range would help increase contrast
Appeal: 4, background is a little busy and detracts a little
Challenge: 5, Fits challenge
Overall Calculated Average Score: 4

Past Time
by gcanter

Comment:
Composition: Composition is pretty static. Maybe a shot that wasn't straight on would help
Technical: Highlights look blown out. If you decrease the brightness/exposure it would leave more texture in the white spots

Deceased
by Blackdog

Comment:
Composition: The clouds on this day look interesting. Maybe crouching down lower to cut out some of the uninteresting ground would help
Technical: Tone range could be expanded quite a bit. Greys are extremely dominant. Shot has a fair amount of grain too.
Appeal: Appeal could be helped by suggestion in my "composition" comment
Challenge: fits challenge ok

Frozen Lake
by palmfrodur

Comment:
Composition: Composition looks good
Technical: Tone range could be expanded a bit so that the greys aren't so dominant
Appeal: This ame shot with more dramatic clouds would be cool
Challenge: Fits challenge ok

Copperbridge Road is known for water and trees that stand on both sides
by tolovemoon

Comment:
Composition: A little busy. Some simplification of shot would help
Technical: Focus could use a little sharpening on foreground
Appeal: A more recognizable point of focus would help the appeal
Challenge: Subject fits challenge ok

Plain Perspective
by Simonjw

Comment:
Composition: 8, Good positioning of fence
Technical: 9, Excellent dark skies to contrast with clouds.
Appeal: 8
Challenge: 8
Overall Calculated Average Score: 8

Tennessee Falls
by lilnukee

Comment:
Composition: 8
Technical: 9, Good tone range. The rocks still hold their texture. Great DOF over whole shot
Appeal: 8
Challenge: 9
Overall Calculated Average Score: 9

Storm over mountain
by JohannesFrank

Comment:
Composition: 8
Technical: 8, Nice tone range
Appeal: 9, Foreground gives nice perspective
Challenge: 8
Overall Calculated Average Score: 8

Urban Bridge
by bobdaveant

Comment:
Composition: 8
Technical: 9, Great tone range. Nice dark sky as well
Appeal: 8
Challenge: 9
Overall Calculated Average Score: 9

Georgian Skies
by jenesis

Comment:
Composition: 8
Technical: 9, Great dark skies to contrast with clouds. I like the dark treeline at the horizon.
Appeal: 8
Challenge: 9, Good tone range
Overall Calculated Average Score: 9