October
by photom

Comment:
Lens flare ruins what could have been a very good shot. (is it possible you put this in with photoshop?, if so WHY?)

September Hurricanes
by Konador

Comment:
What an odd looking tree... Does it grow like this or were you just out in some really crazy weather? Anyway an interesting shot, not quite as exciting as others in this challenge but I bet you will be in the top 15%.

November
by geewhy

Comment:
I like the soft focus in this image, only flaw in this image IMO is the blown out highlights of the reflections in the water. Great shot, one of the best in the challenge.

September
by moodville

Comment:
Very serene scene, great shot, one of my favorites in this challenge.

December
by crabappl3

Comment:
Does he look embarrassed or is it just my imagination? Great lighting, good props and pretty much a good photo. This would look good in an all dog calendar, I wouldn´t get it because I´m not a big dog fan but if I were, I´d get it in a heartbeat. 9

January
by Winterberg

Comment:
Not really a fan of your WB here, it´s a bit too blue but that´s just nitpicking I love this shot, gave it an 8.

Davis Island 2004 - November
by tyt2000

Comment:
Beautiful shot, I would buy this calendar.

Darkness of November in Minnesota
by troylox

Comment:
"Darkness" is a key word here, and I think you have way too much of it with overblown hightligts to boost and then the single red colour. I am sorry but as much as I try I just don´t find anything interesting about this shot, my eye just wanders and finds nothing but that overblown lamppost at the top of this image. Better luck next time and keep shooting.

November....all Soul's Day
by camelotnorth

Comment:
What did you do to that sky? Is it a side effect of using too little quality when using save for web or is it intentional? Anyway, I do not like the effect and I think it brings down an otherwise good image. Please feel free to ignore this comment though if you like it, after all that is all that matters and I have a tendency to be a little bit close minded sometimes.

May
by Rooster

Comment:
Normally a big fan of extremely short DOF I think this is a bit too short, but it´s a strong image and good colours, would be surprised to see it anywhere but in the top 90%.