WWI Bird
by EricSorenW

Comment:
I never give out 1 unless I explain why. First of all, this is way off topic and I have never given a shot I percieve to be off topic a higher grade than 4. secondly this isn´t anything spectacular, it´s just a so so shot of a silhouette of an airplane. The sky isn´t very interesting, the composition is dead centered and well frankly if this were an airplane challenge I would have given it a 3 or a 4. I just don´t find this interesting at all.

Sorry for the rant, but I figured you deserved an explanation as to why I gave it a 1.

Phalaropus lobatus (Red-necked Phalarope)
by andri

Comment:
Very nice, one of my favorites in the challenge, very sharp and good DOF. Like the composition and colours and the reflection is very good. Only to nitpick though, the straws in the bottom are pretty distracting but nevertheless, I gave this a 7.

Watchful
by andrim

Comment:
Not bad, IMHO slightly overexposed and the foilage in the lower right corner is in the way, if only you could have moved to the left and it would have been much better. Excellent sharpness though and good colours.

Welcome to Piccadilly.
by AndrewTO

Comment:
Not bad, but the backround is too distracting for my taste, I would like it more if you had more backround blur. Like the compostion though.

Bottoms Up
by Artan

Comment:
Well I am completely torn with this image. On one hand it´s both underexposed and overexposed, it´s very dark in most places and then you blow out the highlights of all three birds (flamingos?) and normally that just completely ruins a shot for me. On the other hand the composition and moment you captured are very interesting so I don´t really know what to give you. Ended up putting a 5 on this as I am completely torn. If this shot would have had a higher dynamic range I would have given it a 8 or even a 9, even though it´s pretty obviously a zoo shot.

On Wings of Fury
by Ivo

Comment:
Not bad at all but the bokeh is really distracting and doesn´t do anything positive for the shot. Nice clarity of the bird though and I like the slight movement of the feathers.

Playful Messengers
by Sonda

Comment:
Technically this photo isn´t very special but it more than makes up for it by you taking it at the exact correct moment, good job!

Lonely Vigil
by RonRobertson

Comment:
Not bad at all but there are so many good shots in the challenge that I fear this will be lost in the masses. Anyway, it´s not very interesting and it desperatly needs something to make it so, perhaps a nice sunset behind it or some interesting cloud formation next time?

I'm not looking.....
by agwright

Comment:
Very nice sharpness and DOF, only thing about it that I don´t like is that straw is out of place.

Rebar Structure
by eaglebeck

Comment:
I don´t know what filter or effect you used to get that contrasty gloss effect but it´s not really working for me at all, sorry. Other than that it looks like a nice shot, I would have tried to get all of them in the shot though, the guy on the far left has a steel bar over his face.