Glass Marbles in the Sky
by statusquo

Comment:
This is of course just nitpicking but I would have preferred it if that lowest ball were in the frame and not half out, seems very sloppy to me to not have a photo where they were more perfectly aligned as you must have had the opportunity to shoot this again and again. Anyway, nice idea and I like the OOF backround. 6 from me.

Bird Cage
by swamlove

Comment:
Nice idea, pity the lighting isn´t all that good and also the shot seems to have syndromes of hand shake, was the light not enough for you to get a decent shutterspeed? Wish this was lit more mysteriously and was crystal clear and sharp, then I really would have liked it. Anyway, nice idea and keep at it, this is very promising, you just need to work on your technical skills but the imagination and creativity seems to be there.

Tainted Woman
by otisXmike

Comment:
Ooooh! Me like :) Nice effect of the tainted glass, just would have been more artistic to have her nude, hope I don´t sound like a pervert for saying that, just seems more "set up" like this. If she were nude you could give off the illusion she was in the shower or something like that. Anyway, I guess I am more of a perv than I thought I was, hehe :) 7 from me, nice shot.

Window
by DKYoungJr

Comment:
Nicely simplified and love the composition, just think I would have liked it heaps more if the contrast were boosted up, seems a bit flat as it is now.

Plus A Smidgen of Steel
by HornOUBet

Comment:
Ooooh, to be honest I don´t really think this meets the challenge, even though you have glass in the shot, I don´t really feel the shot is about that. In short, I feel you took a shot and made it fit the challenge, not the other way around. However, I just deducted one point for that and thought I should let you know.

Shot is pretty nice, would have given it a 6 in a free study so this got a 5 from me this time.

Portal to Heaven
by Hollywood

Comment:
Pretty cool shot! I really like it, too bad this is basic editing and you couldn´t edit the sky separate, I can just see this with even more dramatic clouds. 7 from me.

through glass, on glass, reflecting glass
by moviealien

Comment:
Nice shot, still I feel like I am looking at a photo of "nothing", but that´s perhaps just my way of thinking, I immediately saw this setting and thought it would be perfect for a model shoot :)

Glass Thoughts
by abranton

Comment:
Nice job on the lighting, wish it was slightly brighter though, the whole shot and my screen is calibrated but this is very clever, great idea.

Devoured by knowledge
by pepitoid

Comment:
I like the lighting in this one, very mysterious.

Fragile
by lwiley212

Comment:
Nice shot, needs something extra though for me to score it above 7 but that is exactly what you got from me and that is a high score from me, means I like it :) Don´t know what´s "missing", can´t put my finger on it.