Riverside
by jamfull

Comment:
Nice shot, looks like a lovely place to visit. However I get the feeling when watching this shot that it would have worked better in landscape, at least I get the feeling I am only looking at half the shot and this is the left part.

River Aurous
by Cutter

Comment:
Well I like the thought behind this image but I find this frame way too busy for my taste. There is simply too much to look at here and the composition doesn´t do anything to lead my eye around the frame. I feel the rocks are simply in the way of that water and that sky is way over the top for me, it just steals attention. Sounds like I gave this shot a 1, wich I didn´t, it got a 5 from me, I neither like it nor dislike it.

Darker rocks, brighter sky and had you moved slightly to your right you never know what I would have given it :)

Heat
by dmadden

Comment:
Nice but I personally would have wanted to see this slightly darker, like a 1/3 or 1/2 stop as I think it would have appealed more to me like that. Also take better care when processing next time, there is some very distinct halo around the are where the land meets the water.

A Country Scene
by Ivory

Comment:
A bit over the top dramatically wise for my taste but other than that pretty good.

Into the West
by illoosi0n

Comment:
This is very nice, I really like the composition. However, take better care when you save it next time cause it will help you score better, this image is only 20kb and you are allowed 200kb so chose better quality next time, there is some really bad artefacting going on around the bridge.

Sea Surchin
by bradical

Comment:
Well whatever the cause, I must say I don´t care for the "look" of this image, the soft focus or blur on the water just doesn´t appeal to my personal taste. Voted 4.

TrainScape
by MCCullen

Comment:
Well sorry but I do believe I have a very open mind on wether an image meets challenges or not but here I just don´t see it. Also the dead center composition of the guy isn´t really working for me. Tried this in black and white?

Voted 2 and purely because I don´t think it meets the challenge.

sunrise
by markdon

Comment:
I like this one, 7.

Oasis in the City
by Grandad

Comment:
Pretty good, I do find those trees to the sides a bit off though, perhaps closer to the church, wider lens and including more of the reflection in the water next time?

Windy day after a storm
by gdub1189

Comment:
Sorry, don´t really care for the grain/lack of contrast and think I have a strong feeling I would have liked it better in color.