Night Mushrooms
by jimmsp

Comment:
Beautiful image

male shadows
by adixion

Comment:
Marvelous profile; an excellent use of the dark. Professional result, with excellent taste and composition. Congratulations.

My Hand
by hann

Comment:
As soon as I find the hand I will provide my comments.

I'm Lust
by lmhr

Comment:
Yeap! Absolutely.

Ink Blot
by originalknappster

Comment:
I was unable to find a reflection is this image. IMHO, as a butterfly photo, it would require more sharpness and focus. Cropping out the wings tip makes it incomplete. I would have left at least one complete wing, and the other could be cropped accordingly with the desired composition.

Cumberland Falls
by daverx7

Comment:
The selected natural setting seems good and atractive, but IMHO this image absolutely requires a perfect technique to compensate for the lack of originality; the reflection of the waterfall would need to be in a perfect focus in order to provide interest. I'm not saying that would be easily achieved.

sunset on Zoltron 4
by photodogg

Comment:
IMHO in very rare ocasions something that is extremely deficient in technique results in an atractive and interesting abstract image. The resulting image here does not inspire me or atract me. It just seems a tremendous technical mishap.

Visions
by stephan

Comment:
IMHO, although there is a reflection on the iris, it's so vague, that it looks more like a defect, than the theme of the image. The contrasted result of the color management makes for a photo that seems to be unfinished and raw, more than attractive or captivating.

The Past
by daysez

Comment:
I will accept your interpretation of the word reflection, as a process of analysis, "reflecting on things past", but IMHO, this theme (9/11) is already far too accessed by all mediums, and the composition is dull and unappealing. Technically, it looses focus on the right lower corner, due perhaps to an ilumination deficiency.

First Submission
by jlr

Comment:
IMHO this is pretty much in focus and the composition of the elements is quite adequate, nevertheless, the reflection, main theme, is vague and unattractive, and the image of an old light bulb with such a grayish, non-contrasting and unappealing background results in a dull photo, that would have probably fared better at the "Garbage" challenge next week.