Through the She-Oaks
by marlin

Comment:
Your horizon is a bit tilted, but otherwise this is a very strong image. Well done.

In Or Out?
by Mark of SRQ

Comment:
If he's climbing in like that, I'm impressed! Good use of relevant framing, nice exposure and an interesting subject.

Four for the wall
by mrorange002

Comment:
Great shot! This doesn't fit the challenge under their definition of framing, so you'll probably not do as well as this photo would in a better suited challenge, but it's a great image regardless. The varied angles and expressions are great, and I like the sharp contrast.

"Rose Tattoo"
by tfarrell23

Comment:
The shells are distracting... could you have flipped the shower curtain backwards for this shot?

FREE-RANGE SNAIL
by Duke Deltree

Comment:
I see a lot of depth here, but no discernable foreground and background.

Like a llama...or an Emu
by Pedro

Comment:
Foreground and background make sense together, great focus, love the subject, excellent sharpness, lovely composition.... This shot has it all! Well done!

Through Iron gate
by k175c

Comment:
Nice fence, and it matches the challenge, but something is definitely missing in this shot. What is on the other side of this fabulous fence that is worth taking a picture of? Please don't think I'm trying to be harsh, but if you could find a bit of fence with something to look at on the other side, it would be much more worthwhile photographically.

Hidden look
by spaque99

Comment:
I particularly like how you arranged your light and used white cardboard to get the reflection in your eye. This would be much better, though, if the keyhole were more carefully cut out.

Hand Framed
by Screechington

Comment:
Yes, it meets the challenge. But as with every shot, you want to ask yourself if it makes sense. What does the hand and the wedding ring have to do with this fabulous building? If you want to prove that you were there, you could probably use this shot to show your friends, since they can also look at your hand and match them up. From the point of view of someone you don't know, who wasn't there, there's no reason for the hand to be there. The idea of framing is that we get the sense of peeking through to see a scene. If I go to see this building, I don't imagine that my first glimpse of it will be peeking through a space between anyone's fingers.

There are three major parts to any good photo (in my opinion): What, How, and Why. You've got the what, this building is a great subject. You've got the How, I like the straight-on angle and the sense of mystery and surroundings created by the large shadow on the front wall. Now you just need to figure out Why you are taking a picture of this building, and if that Why is enhanced by this particular strategy.

Good luck to you, and Happy Shooting!

Frame Continuum
by luv2photo

Comment:
This shot really wouldn't work with memory cards, would it? Very well done. I would have taken off the tape on the end of the film, it doesn't add anything to the shot and ends up being as much of a focal point as the film canister.