Fishin' Hole
by glad2badad

Comment:
Great concept, great composition, great color. My only concern deals with focus, as nothing seems to be fully in focus, notably the bobber and the splash. Don't get me wrong, I am still rating this very high, but I would like to see a bit more sharpness at the bobber.

A Natural Circle
by Jeileen

Comment:
What good eyes you have! I like how the lines here tend to lead my eyes to the spiral. An interesting entry since it is natural, not contrived.

Blue Loop
by alfresco

Comment:
Simple and effective...well done.

AC
by rscorp

Comment:
Great tonal quality to this shot, with more circles than originally meets the eye. This should do well...it better do well, or else!

Drink Up
by Sonifo

Comment:
Cool effect and nice pastel coloring. I'm not quite sure how you achieved this - who knows, maybe its a Macro V outtake, but the overall feel is light and playful. So, good on you.

Slinky
by CreativeFlyPhoto

Comment:
Until I picked up on the shadows, I was going to score this a bit lower, but they really add interest to this shot, notably inside the slinky.

Gone Fishing
by Nikolai1024

Comment:
Given the challenge, I think your central subject is a bit weak. Granted, circles are here, but I wouldn't really have picked up on them that much had I not been directed to. The photo in and of itself is good, moody, and interesting.

Winter comfort
by lakritstroll

Comment:
Great color and contrast. I'd like to see less harsh lighting (normally I like harsh lighting, but to me it doesn't fit here) and maybe a less set-up feel (speaking of 'set-up', I can't talk...look at my photo at the end of the challenge). So, what am I saying? I'm a hypocrite. Again, great color. I'll leave now...thanks.

The glowing orb
by Ronce

Comment:
This shot is very flat and lacks any...'pop', you know? I think a different set up, maybe something else to compliment the orb...something....could really make this an interesting subject.

bale
by john22132

Comment:
I really like your crop here. Maybe a different time of day to give you a more interesting sky. Granted, that is a small detail (but for some reason on DPC, a good sky is a major factor to some voters).