‘Pains’ Of A Closed Textile Plant
by SDW

Comment:
I want to thank everyone that voted on my photograph no matter what you voted; I respect everyones taste and opinion. I thank each and every one of you for taking the time to vote.
I want to send a special thanks to everyone that took the time to comment. I will take everyone of the comments and try to improve upon future photographs.
Thanks to all,
Scott W.

Message edited by author 2004-12-20 01:33:31.

Brokedown Palace
by cpurser

Comment:
Well Done, Congrat's

Colour Two.jpg
by samtrundle

Comment:
Great Shot! Keep up the good work.

Oasis in the Sand
by Kylie

Comment:
Wonderful colors and lines, great job!

Symbolic of a Failing Education System
by dartompkins

Comment:
Again like I commented on another photograph you have met the challenge with a story and emotion behind it, which we all should strive to do. Focus is a little soft; I would of like to have seen it sharper and maybe in a duotone color or B&W but I like the crop. I think you have done a good job and a well deserved 6.

Brokedown Palace
by cpurser

Comment:
This is what separates a photo from a photograph in my opinion. We were asked to do our best in representing ‘broken’ and I have seen so may photos of everyday objects broken but with no emotion or story behind it. I believe a photograph should have a story and emotion behind it or its just a snap shot or photograph that one is trying to appeal to the mass with good technique. I feel you have met the challenge with emotion and a story and at the same time being technically great. I hope others can learn along with myself that something needs to be behind the photograph we submit. Great Job and a well deserved 10.

Fractured Reflection
by samtrundle

Comment:
Ok I can see the link between your title and photograph. While technically sound I find it more distracting. I may be the odd ball out but I don̢۪t see any emotion in the photograph. Just a picture of broken reflections [imo], however not everyone feels the same way about a photograph. I feel you have done a good job of meeting the challenge so I score your photograph a 5. Good luck in the challenge.

Circle Of Life
by faidoi

Comment:
I like your shot because it has emotion behind it while having good detail. I like the B&W you have used and the photo is technically sound. I think we need more photographs on this site that shows emotion not just technically sound photos with no meaning behind it. Good Shot!

buttermilkfalls.jpg
by alanfreed

Comment:
Wonderful Lighting and perfect SS used. I love the mood of this picture. Great Shot

The Dawn of Eternal Peace
by GeneralE

Comment:
Very nice photograph. Wonderful mood. Great Job!