Climb to the Temple of the Moon
by Beagleboy

Comment:
This is a fine image. I would prefer some fill lighting for the foreground. The lower half of the picture is lost in darkness. A 6.

industrial park
by whiteroom

Comment:
While the mood is quite good, the image is kind of ragged and appears oversaturated. A 3.

Once Yellow
by PDavis

Comment:
Very nice abstract. A little dim, I was able to brighten +25 in PS and still not lose deep blacks on my monitor. I would have croppedso as not to leave exposed metal in upper left corner. An 8.

Pyramid Power
by BrennanOB

Comment:
Excellent positioning. Nice texture on thewater. A tad less exposure might have given some more color gradation around tower. Actually, I like this picture more when I desaturate the yellow to -40. The effect is still there but there is more color gradation. An 8.

Follow the Yellow Brick Road
by scalvert

Comment:
This is excellent. The shoes, socks, Toto, road, and "grass." Reflecting light from the back of the models might have helped with the shadows on the road. A 10.

Yellow Protection
by paynekj

Comment:
This would be vastly improved by another light source on the left front. The parts that are lit are well lit and nicely exposed. A 7.

Bulb
by birdyblue

Comment:
Nice control of exposure. The bulb though appears flat. Maybe adding some writing on the surface of the bulb would help with depth. A 9.

Lemon!
by Keys

Comment:
Very nice. This is the best rendition of a lemon slice I have come across so far in this contest. I liked the back lit ones the most so far, but you chose a good healthy specimen, sliced it cleanly, lit it well, placed it on a nicely contrasting background and it looks good enough to eat. The red could be desaturated a little to get rid of blackened corners and Focus Magic at 100% at 1 pixel can sharpen the out of focus blur on the rind. A 10.

"Last Dandelion"
by dphillips

Comment:
Hi, this looked a little flat to me, so I copied it into photoshop and used Focus Magic to reduce the out of focus blur by 50% at 2 pixels. You can try this for free by downloading Focus Magic. Not only was the image nicely sharpened, but it also developed some depth.
Nice idea for yellow, especially this late in the fall. An 8.

M
by nsmith

Comment:
Excellent point of view, framing 10
Clean Image, Limited dynamic range 9
Like colors and form, but not of high interest 8
Overall a 9