get undressed before kill yourself
by pinkorgasm

Comment:
What's the decision? To "kill yourself" or to get undressed before killing yourself. Distracting background, unappealing subject. Better luck in future challenges! I'm afraid I'm scoring this one quite low :(

3 for being in focus and the subject being identifiable (despite its arbitrary nature)

Alex.

Split Second Decisions
by internerd2k

Comment:
Whoah. A push to meet the challenge but that looks really, REALLY cool. A 5 from me, though. Not taking away anything from this shot, it's fantastic, I just don't think it really meets the decisions challenge without the title, which I consider superfluous and ignore during voting. 5 is for your technical acumen and vision :)

to be or not to be...
by christie3

Comment:
The subject doesn't seem to match the title. The only thing that suits the challenge is the title, I'm afraid. This shot is also a little underexposed. Keep shooting, however, and good luck in the next challenge.

Alex

Life Path
by techboy

Comment:
Nice composition, a bit of a stretch to meet the challenge, however. Great photo in a normal context, however, the only thing I would perhaps do is move the boy slightly further back so less of him is chopped off, although I can see where you're going with cutting a little of him off as a space between the near pillar and his body would look awkward. A 5 from me for not meeting the challenge, but good luck in future challenges as well as this one. I'm marking all shots that don't really meet the challenge down (and there're a lot of them). Hope my comment helps you.

Alex.

Anyone For Tea
by renonovado

Comment:
Very nicely composed shot and a pretty, well-arranged subjects. Would have liked the sheet to be less rumpled and I don't like the hotspot on the side of the teapot. Also, this doesn't explicitly meet the challenge so I'm going to give it a fairly mid-range sort of score, and I'm sorry 'bout that but I'm doing it evenly across the board so never fear. I hope my comment helps you :)

Alex.

The path less traveled
by fastaggierunr

Comment:
Nice bag :) Nice idea for the challenge but the shot lacks a certain something, it's just not very punchy. I like the idea though, so a 7 from me.

Rooikat
by Boertjie

Comment:
Doesn't fit the challenge at all, but I'm giving it a 6 because it's a nice photo and you have an Afrikaans title ;)

Alex.

Wear a belt - or wear a tag
by alithenake

Comment:
If the tag didnt' say, "Unbuckled driver" this wouldn't fit the challenge...

But it does, and that makes it a great shot, with great tones that fits the challenge perfectly! I hope people take the time to read the tag, it's very subtle but clear enough and if you get voted down because you 'didn't meet the challenge' it really will be tragically unfair.

Good luck, a 9 from me.

Alex.

Take a seat ...
by e301

Comment:
Whoah. This is quite a weird shot, makes you kind of second guess your eyes. It kind of fits the challenge, good enough for me. I'm not so sure why I like this shot as much as I do, but I do...so thanks :)

An 8 From me, good work sir or madame.

hmm- the worm or the bread
by joyinlight

Comment:
I can see a clear decision being made! Marvellous! :)

A 7 from me, good job.